Skip to main content
You are the owner of this article.
You have permission to edit this article.
Jury finds Boswell guilty of murder in killing of Sydney Loofe
breaking topical featured

Jury finds Boswell guilty of murder in killing of Sydney Loofe

  • Updated
  • 0

LEXINGTON — After making it through a second trial, hearing the terrible details about their daughter's killing and dismemberment nearly three years ago, Sydney Loofe's parents sat surrounded by family in a courtroom annex watching video of the verdict as it was read in a courtroom a block away Wednesday.

Bailey Boswell was guilty of first-degree murder.

Guilty of improper disposal of human skeletal remains.

And guilty of conspiracy to commit murder.

In closing arguments, defense paints Boswell as another of Trail's victims

On the video feed, Boswell kept her eyes down, as she had when the state showed graphic images of Loofe's dismembered remains to the jury.

Loofe's mom, Susie, and her sister, MacKenzie, wiped away tears.

After deliberating for just more than three hours, the jury of eight men and four women returned the verdict at 12:45 p.m., finding Boswell, 26, guilty.

Boswell's attorney, Todd Lancaster, declined to comment on the verdict, saying it would be inappropriate at this time, given that it's a death penalty case and Boswell will face an aggravation and mitigation trial later before a three-judge panel. 

The hearing, where Boswell will learn if she will get life in prison or death for the crimes, wasn't immediately set.

Boswell looks into her lap as photos from autopsy shown to jury

A hearing for her co-defendant, Aubrey Trail, is set to start Dec. 15, following a Saline County jury last year finding him guilty of the murder and conspiracy charges. Trail pleaded guilty to unlawful disposal of human remains prior to trial.

He maintained then that he killed Loofe accidentally while choking her during sex, then got rid of the body because he didn't think police would believe him. He has denied Boswell had anything to do with it.

Prosecutors say Trail and Boswell worked lockstep to recruit young women in a conspiracy to kill and ultimately chose Loofe as their victim. And that Boswell lured her to their Wilber apartment the night of Nov. 15, 2017, under the guise of a date after matching on the dating app Tinder.

Within 24 minutes of getting there, Boswell and Trail attacked and killed her, Assistant Attorney General Mike Guinan said in closing arguments Tuesday. 

Lancaster contended that Boswell was another of Trail's victims and that, like other women who testified about the pair's talk of witchcraft, torture and killing, he had indoctrinated her to where she feared the punishment he would dole out if she didn't obey. 

The jury rejected the idea, taking just slightly longer than it took Trail's jury to find him guilty last year.

Witness at Boswell trial: 'I paid three psychologists to forget this incident'

Walking out after the verdict, juror Ed Scheuffele of Overton told the Omaha World-Herald: “As you went along, the evidence just added up, more and more and more.”

Logan Lashman of Gothenburg, the jury foreman, said that each of the jurors had their own opinions, "but they agreed on the facts."

They were unanimous on the first vote on each count, he said.

“It wasn’t close for me,” fellow juror Jerry Fales of Cozad said.

Boswell trial turns to talk of witchcraft: 'To get your power, you would have to breathe in someone's last breath'

In a news release, Nebraska Attorney General Doug Peterson said he was pleased with Wednesday's decision.

"We once again offer our sympathy to the Loofe family with our hope the justice system provides some measure of condolement to them for the loss of their daughter Sydney," he said.

The Loofe and Boswell families, both watching from the annex, left without comment. 

Susie Loofe reported her daughter missing Nov. 16, 2017, after she learned that Sydney  didn't show up for work. Her disappearance sparked a massive search for her, then a manhunt for Boswell and Trail and ultimately to the discovery of Loofe's remains in plastic bags scattered along gravel roads in central Nebraska’s Clay County.

Boswell could become the first woman sentenced to death in the state.

Loofe texted friend after first date with Boswell: 'I hope she doesn't have a boyfriend'

Photos from Bailey Boswell's trial

Photos of Aubrey Trail in court

Reach the writer at 402-473-7237 or

On Twitter @LJSpilger


Sign up for our Crime & Courts newsletter

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Public safety reporter

Lori Pilger is a Norfolk native and University of Nebraska-Lincoln graduate who has been a public safety reporter for the Journal Star since 2005.

Related to this story

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News

Husker News