A female Lincoln firefighter suing the department over alleged discrimination and retaliation is asking a judge to order an independent investigation after, she says, a captain at the center of the case "abandoned" her team in a burning building.
Amanda Benson's attorney, Kelly Brandon, says despite multiple complaints from Benson about Capt. Shawn Mahler's conduct over the past several years, the city and Lincoln Fire & Rescue administration have refused to discipline him.
Now, she is asking Senior U.S. District Judge Richard Kopf to order the city to immediately initiate disciplinary proceedings against Mahler, prohibit him from being sent to fires and appoint an independent, third party to investigate the complaint about his actions at a fire in April.
"Plaintiff is engaged in a dangerous profession where teamwork is absolutely critical," the Gretna attorney wrote. "Plaintiff, and those who happen to work on her team, face obvious irreparable harm if Mahler is allowed to continue retaliating against her while this litigation proceeds."
People are also reading…
According to court records, Mahler told an administrative officer investigating the complaint that he had been confused about who was assigned to him.
The city hasn't yet filed a response to the motion.
"Following receipt of the parties' written materials, the court may or may not hold an evidentiary hearing," Kopf said in an order this week.
On Friday, City Attorney Yohance Christie said he couldn't comment on personnel issues but said the fire department always investigates complaints. It's the department's responsibility as an employer.
"The Fire Department is going to continue to work to create an environment where all employees, including Ms. Benson and Mr. Mahler, feel safe," he said.
In 2018, Benson sued, alleging that the city turned a blind eye to complaints about a hostile work environment, exonerated employees who contributed to it and failed to take steps to fix it.
Specifically, she alleged Mahler refused to train her on general station procedures, truck functions, roof venting and rope rigging because she is a woman and repeatedly expressed his resistance to female firefighters.
After an internal investigation in 2016, the city found no reason for disciplinary action and told Benson to return to Station 8 or give up her assignment.
She now works at Station 1. But in an affidavit filed last week, Benson said it's not uncommon for her and Mahler to be dispatched to the same fire or crash, as they were April 26 when a fire broke out at a cardboard warehouse.
Benson said her crew was assigned to help Mahler's crew with ventilation, but Mahler ignored her when she repeatedly asked him how they could help.
When her team followed him in the warehouse, she said, Mahler suddenly walked away and left them "without communication, assignment or direction on how or where to proceed."
Because of heavy smoke and low visibility, she said she had to use a thermal-imaging camera to find the fire and a hose line to find the way out.
Benson thinks it was retaliation for a complaint she'd made four days earlier alleging Mahler disparaged her to another firefighter.
The lawsuit followed two others by then-Capts. Brian Giles and Troy Hurd, alleging they faced retaliation for reporting harassment of female firefighters.
In 2019, a federal jury awarded Hurd $1.1 million. The judgment later was reduced by a judge and the city agreed to pay Hurd $600,000 to avoid a second trial.
Last year, the city agreed to pay Giles $280,000 to settle his lawsuit.
Photos: Firefighters in action
Photos: Firefighters in Action

A firefighter backs off from the heat of the flames Sunday coming from the roof of Romantix, 921 O St. Fire crews responded to the adult novelty store blaze at about 9 a.m. and needed most of the afternoon to extinguish the flames. The building is described as a total loss, but no one was injured.
Photos: Firefighters in Action

A massive plume of fire erupts in front of Lincoln firefighters Nick Thill (left) and Mark Sullivan moments after Sullivan ventilated the roof with the blade of his chainsaw at a working fire at 1717 A Street in Lincoln on Wednesday evening, April 6, 2011.
Photos: Firefighters in Action

With a fire hose at the ready, Lincoln firefighters look over the underside of a pickup truck which rolled over at the intersection of 16th and L Streets Monday afternoon, April 11, 2011. The scanner call mentioned there was leaking gasoline. One person was taken away on a stretcher to an ambulance.
Photos: Firefighters in Action

Marie Yost (left) and Nancy Harter (right) watch from the median on O Street as Lincoln firefighters pour water on the smouldering remains of the Lincoln Public Schools adminstration building on Tuesday morning, May 31, 2011. Harter, who worked in the building for 11 years, said a supervisor contacted staff at 6 a.m. to let them know of the fire.
Photos: Firefighters in Action

Heavy smoke envelopes the house fire at 236 S. 27th Street as Lincoln firefighters apply water to the attic fire on Tuesday afternoon, August 16, 2011.
Photos: Firefighters in Action

Lincoln Firefighter Nancy Engelbrecht (right) attempts to comfort Shari Elder as Elder watches smoke pour from the apartment building where she lives on Wednesday, March 13, 2013, at 27th and Randolph streets.
Photos: Firefighters in Action

Protected against the 1600 degree temperatures emanating from the fire pit, Dorchester Vol. Fire Dept. firefighter Brant Pracheil tosses the Stars and Stripes into the flames on Tuesday, June 14, 2016, during a flag retirement ceremony at the Dorchester American Legion Post 264. A total of 1957 unserviceable flags from the communities of Dorchester, York, Fairmont, Lincoln, Wilber, Fairbury and Crete were retired from life during the ceremony.
Photos: Firefighters in Action

The Stars and Strips opens to the swirling wind from the ladder of Lincoln Fire & Rescue Truck 1 on Friday, March 31, 2017, during the bridge dedication ceremony for Staff Sgt. Patrick Hamburger at the Spirit of '76 Armory.
Photos: Firefighters in Action

Surrounded by black smoke, a Lincoln Fire Department firefighter uses a pike pole to open the porch ceiling at the scene of a house fire on Wednesday, Jan. 2, 2019, at 1800 Euclid Avenue.
Photos: Firefighters in Action

Matt Barnard, with Beatrice Rural Fire District, uses a torch to spread flames during a prescribed burn of 45 acres of the prairie at Homestead National Monument of America on Wednesday, Oct. 20, 2010.
Photos: Firefighters in Action

Lincoln Fire and Rescue teams help Alex Lekai and his mother, not pictured, evacuate from her south bottoms home on Thursday, May 7, 2015.
Photos: Firefighters in Action

Cuddling her grandson's dog Milo, homeowner Deborah Ganz is consoled by a neighbor as she watches her garage burn on Wednesday, April 6, 2016, in west Lincoln.
Photos: Firefighters in Action

A Lincoln firefighter directs his hose on the roof of La Mexicana Market & Restaurant, 17th and P Streets, on Monday, April 13, 2015.
Reach the writer at 402-473-7237 or lpilger@journalstar.com.
On Twitter @LJSpilger.