Skip to main content
You have permission to edit this article.
Why the book that inspired HBO's 'The Undoing' is so much better than the series

Why the book that inspired HBO's 'The Undoing' is so much better than the series

  • Comments
"You Should Have Known" by Jean Hanff Korelitz.

"You Should Have Known" by Jean Hanff Korelitz. (Grand Central Publishing/TNS)

Sometimes, the book is better.

Like maybe a lot of you, I got pulled into "The Undoing" on HBO a couple of months back. A psychological thriller starring Nicole Kidman as a well-off New York City therapist and Hugh Grant as her debonair doctor husband who's definitely not what he seems (and possibly may be a murderer), it was a series that promised a lot (think "Big Little Lies," Manhattan version) and ultimately didn't really deliver. (Except for Kidman's character's coats, which were sublime and which absolutely deserve to be spun off into their own series.)

But I was intrigued enough to seek out the novel the series was based on — particularly after reading that its author, Jean Hanff Korelitz, said in interviews that she had no idea how the series would end, as her book was quite different. Off I went to track down "You Should Have Known," published in 2014 — and oh, it's so much better. (Minor spoiler alert here.)

Like the series, "You Should Have Known" has therapist Grace at its center; unlike the series, it's solely about Grace, because her husband Jonathan doesn't appear at all — the story begins after his disappearance (Grace initially thinks he's at a medical conference), and we only come to know him through Grace's memories. And, since we're not distracted wondering when Grant will show up and say something charming, we can focus on the book's fascinating premise: how a woman who has based her career in telling others how to pick the right person can do exactly the opposite for herself, and how a picture-perfect life can excruciatingly unravel.

Having watched the series doesn't spoil this book it all; it just makes you read it appreciating the book's nuances (Grace and her family, for example, are nowhere near as wealthy as they are in the screen version), its perfectly spun tension, and its portrait of a smart woman slowly realizing her own blind spots. Check it out — and note that Korelitz has another literary thriller out in May, "The Plot."

By intriguing coincidence (what is crime fiction if not intrigue?), I happened to read another suspense novel this month that had a very different translation to the screen — but in this case, both book and movie are terrific. Dorothy B. Hughes' "In a Lonely Place," originally published in 1947, was reissued a few years ago with a thoughtful afterword by Megan Abbott (another splendid spinner of psychological thrillers). It's old-school noir, peppered with skies that look like "watered gray silk" and characters for whom "something was there behind the curtain of her eyes," set in a bygone Los Angeles full of fog and cigarette smoke and secrets.

Dix Steele — yes, that's his name, surely someone's since borrowed it for a porn movie — is the heart of darkness at its center, a former World War II fighter pilot who's in L.A. supposedly writing a novel, but his true pursuits are rage-fueled, under cover of those moody nights. Hughes puts us inside his head, inside that rage, letting us peek out at the world as he sees it. Though Dix's consciousness isn't a very nice place to visit, I loved Hughes' hard-boiled prose, her moodily poetic descriptions of the city, and her unexpected heroine. In 1950, "In a Lonely Place" became a classic Nicholas Ray film noir, starring Humphrey Bogart and Gloria Grahame; its plot takes some significant turns from the book and it becomes an unexpected, heartbreaking love story, anchored by one of Bogie's greatest performances.

And finally, in honor of Black History Month, a few recommendations:

* Barbara Neely is the author of the wonderful four-book Blanche White series, with an opinionated Black maid-turned-amateur-sleuth at its center. "Blanche on the Lam," from 1992, is the opener. Neely, who died last year, was awarded Grand Master from the Mystery Writers of America before her death.

* Chester Himes (1909-1984) wrote in a variety of genres, but is best known for his Harlem Detective series: nine books, written mostly in the 1950s and '60s, featuring NYPD detectives Grave Digger Jones and Coffin Ed Johnson. Himes, who spent the second half of his life living in Europe, was awarded the Grand Prix de Littérature Policière prize in 1958. The 1991 movie "A Rage in Harlem," with Gregory Hines and Forest Whitaker, is based on his work.

* Created by Eleanor Taylor Bland (1944-2010), police detective Marti MacAlister (a former Chicago cop who relocates to a small Illinois town after the death of her husband) was among the first Black female professional detectives of fiction. The 13-book series begins with 1992's "Dead Time."


Stay up-to-date on what's happening

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

Here are the bestsellers for the week that ended Saturday, Feb. 27, compiled from data from independent and chain bookstores, book wholesalers and independent distributors nationwide, powered by NPD BookScan © 2021 NPD Group. (Reprinted from Publishers Weekly, published by PWxyz LLC. © 2021, PWxyz LLC.) HARDCOVER FICTION 1. "The Four Winds" by Kristin Hannah (St. Martin’s) Last week: 2 2. "A ...

On the afternoon of Jan. 24, two children's authors were lured to a Zoom meeting under false pretenses. David LaRochelle of White Bear Lake and Mike Wohnoutka of Minneapolis had been invited to take part in a panel discussion for the American Library Association. But when they clicked on the Zoom link, there was no panel — instead, they saw seven people beaming at them. "We have good news," ...

Here are the bestsellers for the week that ended Saturday, Feb. 27, compiled from data from independent and chain bookstores, book wholesalers and independent distributors nationwide, powered by NPD BookScan © 2020 NPD Group. (Reprinted from Publishers Weekly, published by PWxyz LLC. © 2020, PWxyz LLC.) HARDCOVER FICTION 1. The Four Winds. Kristin Hannah. St. Martin's 2. A Court of Silver ...

"The paradox is that you can create quite a lot of emotion, when you have a voice that isn't inclined to express emotion." Kazuo Ishiguro, the Nobel Prize-winning novelist whose works include "The Remains of the Day" and "Never Let Me Go," could be talking about a number of his characters, but in this case he's describing the main character in his new novel, "Klara and the Sun." Klara, the ...

Spring is coming ... soon? Here are six new paperbacks to help you get there — four fiction, two memoir, all recommended. "The Girl with the Louding Voice" by Abi Daré (Dutton, $14.99). This debut novel from Nigerian British author Daré was a New York Times bestseller, about a teenage girl in a Nigerian village who is determined to get an education but is pushed into a traditional early ...

In the near present, a woman whose marriage is crumbling lifts a tiny sky-blue vial from the bank of the Thames River. In 1791, a 12-year-old girl who has helped commit a murder fills that vial with a potion she hopes will change her life. What links them, besides that bit of blue glass, is the subject of "The Lost Apothecary," a debut novel by Sarah Penner, who lives in St. Petersburg. The ...

In 1999, Sister Souljah published her first novel, "The Coldest Winter Ever," considered by some to be the mother of what's been called urban or street fiction and its first classic. Its heroine, Winter Santiaga, the pampered daughter of a Brooklyn drug kingpin, uses her feminine wiles and hustler mentality to survive after her father's empire suddenly comes crashing down. "The Coldest Winter ...

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News

Husker News