Local View: Lessons from a beetle on Endangered Species Act's power

2013-06-30T23:57:00Z 2013-07-01T13:46:10Z Local View: Lessons from a beetle on Endangered Species Act's powerBy BUFFALO BRUCE McINTOSH JournalStar.com
June 30, 2013 11:57 pm  • 

This year marks the 40th anniversary of the Endangered Species Act, our nation’s premier environmental law, which highlights the critical role biological diversity plays in maintaining a functioning space for all living beings.

Nebraskans don’t have to look far to find examples of the act’s remarkable record of preventing extinction and helping plant and animal species recover.

During the past century, more than 230 species of birds have been documented on our salt marshes, including such species as the piping plover and peregrine falcon, both of which have recovered from the brink of extinction with help of the Endangered Species Act.

But the plight of the Salt Creek tiger beetle here in Lancaster County is a stark reminder that the success of the act over the next four decades, and beyond, is limited to our willingness to follow the best available science rather than the most expedient politics.

With only a few hundred individuals remaining, not only is our little brown, half-inch-long beetle considered one of the rarest insects on the planet, it is struggling to survive in one of the most restricted ranges of any U.S. insect: 90 percent of its salt-marsh habitat has been destroyed or severely degraded.

Yet, earlier this month the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, announcing a long-awaited decision on how much critical habitat should be set aside for the beetle, proposed that only 1,110 acres be designated in Lancaster and Saunders counties. The decision stands in sharp contrast to a 2005 recommendation by scientists that 36,000 acres of habitat were needed to be protected to ensure the beetle’s recovery.

Since the Bush administration, our government agencies have been taking a politically handcuffed, extremely timid approach to implementing the full power of the Endangered Species Act.

We saw it last summer in the decision not to extend the act’s protection to the critically imperiled dunes sagebrush lizard, an outcome fueled by heavy lobbying from oil, gas and livestock industries. We saw it again late last year with the scientifically indefensible decisions to cut 90 percent of the mountain caribou’s high-mountain habitat. And if we aren’t careful, this politically compromised approach is likely to continue.

Led by U.S. Rep. Doc Hastings, R-Wash., Republicans have pushed hard in recent years to weaken the Endangered Species Act. Hastings, who chairs the powerful House Committee on Natural Resources, routinely has attacked both the act and the conservationists, like me, who work to enforce it.

Not surprisingly, the facts don’t support Hastings' claims that legal petitions from conservationists forcing the Fish and Wildlife Service to make timely decisions about protecting imperiled species are a waste of time and taxpayer money.

A study published last year in the journal Science found that citizen-initiated lawsuits did a better job than the Fish and Wildlife Service of identifying the nation’s most-imperiled plants and animals. Dan Ashe, director of the service, has said he believes petitions from citizen and conservation groups are one of the strengths of the Endangered Species Act.

A perfect example is the recent lawsuit featuring the burying beetle, which forced the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service to do a better job of limiting illegal “take” of protected species. That litigation also brought greater public awareness to why the 12 million-acre Sand Hills region is referred to by scientists as “the most important biologically intact focal area within the Great Plains.” A side effect of that litigation was to assist the U.S. Department of State with the November 2011 determination to delay the Keystone XL pipeline until an alternative route circumventing the environmentally sensitive Sand Hills was solidified.

It’s clear only with the help of citizens can the Endangered Species Act continue its unequaled record of success: In its first four decades, the law has prevented the extinction of 99 percent of the more than 1,400 plants and animals it protects.

To make sure that success continues for another 40 years, all we have to do is follow the science, not the politics.

Formerly with the Smithsonian and now living in Chadron, Buffalo Bruce McIntosh’s history of environmental lawsuits started in 1973 where he prevailed in a case decision from the U.S. Supreme Court.

Copyright 2015 JournalStar.com. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.


Letter, 4/1: Preempt voter fraud

This is to all those who are against voter ID requirements ("Legislature shelves voter photo ID bill," Feb. 18), I was hoping one of you could answer a couple of questions. One main argument I've heard is that it would create too much hardship or cost for some people. Here is a partial list …

Letter, 4/1: Sasse, Fischer oblivious

I should have expected that our Nebraska senators would sign on to Sen. Tom Cotton's letter to the Ayatollah of Iran to sabotage ongoing nuclear negotiations ("Sasse, Fischer and Iran," March 23).

Letter, 4/1: Remove Chambers

It is time to declare that Ernie Chambers cannot serve the public who elected him ("Chambers and McCoy go head to head," March 30). His desire to impair law enforcement, his inflammatory hatred of police and racial bias is truly a disservice to the state. Remove him from office by any method…

Letter, 4/1: Lamm hasn't earned trust

Recently, my wife and I received identical mailings from the "Cyndi Lamm for City Council" campaign. These two fliers were identical except for one thing. The banner line for the registered Democrat was "Pro-Jobs, Pro-Growth, Pro-Lincoln," while the Republican one stated "Pro-Life, Pro-Growt…

Letter, 4/1: Right to wear helmet, or not

Once again the Legislature has protected motorcyclists from themselves ("Lawmakers hit brakes on repeal of motorcycle helmet law," March 23). I used to be frustrated with the mandatory helmet law, but now I'm mainly annoyed. Sen. Hilkemann led the charge against repeal by arguing that "gover…

Letter, 3/31: Use pepper spray, not gun

I have just a simple question to the cop who shot the 9-year-old pit bull the other night because it was allegedly growling at him and coming towards him even though it was chained up ("Family's dog dies after being shot by LPD officer," March 21). Have you ever in your life heard of a thing…

Letter, 4/1: Beutler a positive voice

Two cards from mayoral candidates arrived in the mail on March 25. One card with all positive statements. The other replete with negativism. Mayor Beutler’s all positive. Andy Stebbing's all negative. Whom would you rather have as your next mayor, someone negative or someone with a positive …