Editorial, 6/25: Political game harms Medicare

2010-06-24T23:45:00Z 2010-06-28T15:33:52Z Editorial, 6/25: Political game harms Medicare JournalStar.com
June 24, 2010 11:45 pm

Congress this week reached an atrocious new low in its recent handling of Medicare reimbursements to physicians.

The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services this week began enforcing a 21 percent cut in physician Medicare payments. An estimated 50 million claims were affected. The scale of the disruption, although temporary, is unprecedented.

By law, the cuts were supposed to go into effect on June 1. CMS held off actually making the cuts as long as it could on the assumption that Congress would get around to reversing the cut, as it has done repeatedly in the past.

The expected reversal was delayed because Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid for a time held physician reimbursements hostage, trying to use the issue as leverage to round up votes for a stimulus spending bill. Then he suddenly pulled physician reimbursement funding out of the stimulus package; it quickly passed on a separate vote. Reid's decision surprised and irritated House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, who refused to allow a House vote, until finally relenting on Thursday.

With Congress at an impasse, CMS officials on Monday said they could wait no longer. The most immediate effect is that doctors all across the country, including those in Lincoln and elsewhere is Nebraska, will receive checks

21 percent lower than anticipated. Those hurt the most will be doctors with a high proportion of Medicare patients.

"The damage has been done," Robert Doherty, senior vice president of governmental affairs and public policy for the American College of Physicians, told the Wall Street Journal's Health Blog. "This has created a lot of havoc, and it's a bigger issue than the two or three or four days when claims were being processed at these (21 percent lower) levels."

Dr. Cecil B. Wilson, president of the American Medical Association, said in a statement that Congress was playing "Russian roulette" with seniors' health care.

"This is no way to run a major health coverage program," he said.

The current spectacle of congressional ineptitude may persuade more physicians to limit the number of Medicare patients they see. The number of physicians refusing to see new Medicare patients already is setting a new high, according to USA Today.

The refusal by Congress to act comes with a price tag of its own. Assuming that Congress eventually will revoke the cut, the claims will be reprocessed at a cost of about $15 million, based on CMS estimates.

Both major political parties share blame for creating the current mess. In 1992, Congress approved a formula for determining reimbursement rates. In 2001, Congress started approving fictitious cuts in Medicare fees in order to make the federal budget look better. Since then, for nearly 10 years, Congress continued to make fictitious cuts, and then negated them with "temporary" delays. Now the accumulated gap is 21 percent.

Democrats refused to address the problem while shoving the health reform package through Congress. Covering the real cost of Medicare would have made it impossible to claim that the reform package would lower annual deficits.

So the problem persists. It will stay that way until Congress finally puts aside brinkmanship and political games and goes to work on a long-term solution.

Copyright 2015 JournalStar.com. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.


Letter, 3/26: Water ruling sets bad precedent

Farmers in the Republican River Basin were shortchanged by the way in which the dispute with Kansas over water flowing across our southern border was resolved ("U.S. Supreme Court decides water dispute," Feb. 24). Pumping our groundwater and dumping it downstream to satisfy Kansas' demands t…

Letter, 3/26: Tax carbon polluters

A recent letter ("Truth in climate change," March 16) reported on the talk by economist Dr. Gerald Metcalf at the E.N. Thompson forum on World Issues, where he advocated a rebated carbon tax to "make our competitive markets more efficient."

Letter, 3/26: Question crime statistics

To say that the violent crime rate is actually down 30 percent in Lincoln since Mayor Beutler took office, you have to look at all crimes. Crimes are broken down into two parts: Part 1 are felonies and Part 2 are less serious crimes. Both need to be examined and when added together, only the…