Russia has gone too far in Georgia
The United States and its western allies have few cards to play in the power struggle with Russia over the future of Georgia.
But it’s becoming increasingly clear that it must play the cards that it has or Russian will become increasingly emboldened and think it can disregard the sovereignty of its neighbors with impunity.
Despite promises that it would withdraw, Russian forces remain near the Georgian port city of Poti.
There’s little doubt that Russia’s actions have alarmed the former Soviet bloc nations that gained independence when the former Soviet Union broke up.
Ukrainian President Victor Yushchenko wrote in a column published in the Washington Post: “The tragic events in Georgia also exposed the lack of preventative mechanisms by the United Nations, the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe and other international organizations.”
In Poland, the Russian invasion of Georgia triggered a rapid public embrace of a U.S. plan to install interceptor missiles on Polish soil.
Journalist Kamil Tchorek, who grew up in Poland under Soviet domination in the 1970s and 1980s, wrote in a column in Britain’s Guardian, “Poles are convinced that the time for treading softly around the Russian bear has passed.”
Meanwhile, Russian officials mocked diplomatic efforts to punish Russia. Referring to talk of blocking Russia from joining the World Trade Organization, former President Vladimir Putin said, “We don’t feel or see any advantages from membership, if they exist at all.”
Despite that overt disdain, and despite the European Union’s dependency on Russia for natural gas and oil, the West does have some economic leverage over Russia.
A possible vulnerability is the circle of rich oligarchs around Putin and President Dmitri Medvedev who are active in the global economy, making investments around the world, including the United States. Those assets could be subject to seizure under international law if Russia violates international law in Georgia or elsewhere.
Already the events in Georgia have prompted investors, including some Russians, to pull assets out of Russia. Its currency reserves have plummeted in recent days, the Washington Post reported.
There’s some merit to the observation that Georgia is not blameless in the current dispute, but the disproportionate Russian response was inexcusable.
The long-term Western response to Russia’s aggression in Georgia must be intelligent and deft, but there must be one. Russia’s actions cannot go unchallenged, or the pattern will be repeated.

Facebook
del.icio.us
Fark It
Reddit


Post Your Comment
Standards and RulesYour posted comment will appear after it has been approved.
Frequently asked questions about story commenting.
All due to the spineless response of the United States Government and the UN. Get used to it. "
Zoomie wrote on September 2, 2008 7:51 am:
What the US needs to be cautious about (but sadly McSame wants to set up a direct confrontation, apparently confident Russia will ALWAYS back down, a very, very dangerous assumption) is the wish of several formerly Soviet Block nations who want into NATO ONLY because they want the guarantee that if Russa attacks them, we'll rush in to defend them. Traditional conservatives are absolutely correct that this is NOT in our interest, and we can only lose in such a situation. Unless the nations involved are in some way critical to the US, we should allow Russia its sphere of influence. "
misplaced wrote on September 2, 2008 8:18 am:
THE OTHER JR wrote on September 2, 2008 8:33 am:
Tzi wrote on September 2, 2008 10:57 am:
The invasion of Georgia gave Russia a chance to give its troops experience in real combat conditions. It gave them a chance to try out all their new weapons and strategies. It also gave them insight in to what western powers would do if it decided to invade other nations. There is nothing to stop it from going after other lands. Already Russia is threatening Moldavia and the Ukraine.
The similarities between the aggressions now and the aggressions going on in the 1930s should send a cold shiver down the spines of anyone who's studied the history.
England and France let Hitler have Austria in their attempt to maintain the peace.
Make no mistake, if it does get worse Russia will be controlling all the factors. No international agreement (including NATO) is going to stop them. "
Matt Bernhardt wrote on September 2, 2008 12:57 pm:
No.
They did the only thing they could do, much like the United States has done in this so called "War on Terror", fight back.
Yes they should leave the native lands of Georgia, but as far as I can tell, they have won this war and deserve at least the lands of South Ossetia and Abkhazia which want to leave Georgia anyway.
They have won this war fair and square and if the US gets to put a democracy in Iraq, the Russians can install whatever kind of govornment they want in these two lands. Fair is Fair. Lets just not forget who the aggressor was. "
Matt Bernhardt wrote on September 2, 2008 1:39 pm:
I am not a US military hater or "hippie" or anything like that, but I do not like it when history is rewritten in American favor or written against past or present enemies of the state (Russia). "
Funny wrote on September 2, 2008 5:18 pm:
As far as a response, what would anyone have us do? Even if we werent mired in Iraq and Afghanistan , do we risk world war 3 for Georgia? People rightly scream when we lose 4000 troops in Iraq but there will no one left to scream if we all die in a global thermonuclear war. "
JT Hutt wrote on September 2, 2008 5:31 pm:
It disgusts me to say this, "Maybe Putin is telling the truth." Bush McCain, tell us again about your moral authority on the world stage. Our credibility is shot. This isn't Change. This is more of the Same. "
whatever wrote on September 2, 2008 5:44 pm:
Matt Bernhardt wrote on September 3, 2008 3:03 pm:
I'm sorry. I didn't mean for it to come across that I was criticizing the US. I am just sick and tired of the people who will blatantly support the US in Iraq yet condemn Russia for their actions. Its the same thing, why is what they are doing so much worse?
In all, I am just fed up with the Republican foreign policy of "The US is the world's policeman" yet I am also equally fed up with Democratic social programs and "we all must be equal" attitudes. Some people work very hard for their wealth and should be entitled to it.
I don't know what I am going to do on election day, probably cry, and drink alot. "