Now
Fair
60°
High
81°
Low
62°

Cindy Lange-Kubick: For Ezekiel, who died alone

Text Size: 
Tools Sponsor

Saturday, Jan 12, 2008 - 11:55:59 pm CST

Ezekiel Berry lived just 21 months.

Monday, the toddler with fair skin and hair like peach fuzz was found on the floor of an Omaha apartment near the body of his 43-year-old mother.

Janelle Browning was on the couch. The TV was on.

Kitchen cupboards were open and their contents scattered, as if the boy had foraged for food, news reports said.

Christmas presents were under the tree, still unwrapped.

It’s a story that takes your breath away.

A child inside an apartment. Unable to open a door. Unable to call for help. Or fill a glass with water. Or understand why Mommy won’t wake up.

Who is to blame when a little boy dies in an apartment in the middle of a city of half a million people?

Anyone? No one? Everyone?

That’s the thought that won’t let go. All those days and nights and no one came to the rescue.

Not a neighbor missing two faces in the hallway.

Not the little boy’s father, whose weekend to visit came and went without a phone call.

Not a grandma knocking at the door to check on her grandson.

No one who expected a mother and child for Christmas dinner and called to see why they hadn’t arrived.

No one.

Until two weeks after Christmas, when a friend of Browning’s finally called police.

By then it was far too late.

A lifetime ago, working my way toward a double major in journalism and sociology, I took a class called urban sociology.

I’m not sure I saved my notes, but I remember talking about anomie — a strange new word that described that sense of disconnection and isolation in the midst of people, a breakdown of social structures, a feeling of anonymity.

In small towns we know our neighbors, their habits, when things are out of place.

But the mechanics of the modern city, even with all that humanity jammed so closely together, or perhaps because of it, often made short work of intimacy.

Thoreau wrote about it. “City life is millions of people being lonesome together.”

He wrote those words long before there were suburbs and garage doors that open and shut by magic. Where we can live a back yard away from someone for years and never know them.

On my street in an old part of town, renters come and go without my ever knowing their names, or even their faces.

I wouldn’t miss them if they disappeared.

But surely someone would. At least that’s what we all hope.

That we are bound together by blood or love or work or proximity to somebody who would notice if we vanished. Someone who would care enough to knock on the door.

But people die alone.

Often they are old. Their obituaries appear in newspapers, with no survivors listed.

But a child?

A child whose age was not yet measured in years, but in 30-day life-altering increments — new word, new tooth, new discovery — dying alone, without comfort, is hard to bear.

After the news of Ezekiel and his mother appeared, relatives were interviewed.

One of Browning’s brothers explained how Ezekiel’s mother had distanced herself from her family, even as she recovered from addiction and put her life back together.

A brother who said his sister’s closest neighbor was gone a lot and folks at the apartment building “aren’t that close of a group.”

A brother who said he’d never met the little boy his sister called Zeke, whose body was cremated Saturday along with his mother’s, their ashes mingled.

A brother who said he was told when children die of dehydration “they just cry themselves to sleep and never wake up.”

No foul play was suspected, the newspaper story said.

The mother and son died of natural causes.

Or as natural a cause as a 21-month old child wandering alone in an apartment in the middle of a city of a half-million people, and dying on the floor, undiscovered for days, can ever possibly be.

Reach Cindy Lange-Kubick at 473-7218 or clangekubick@journalstar.com.


$1 Sunday Delivery - Subscribe Today!
Local > Back to Top of Story

All posts to JournalStar.com are subject to our Terms and Standards.
Your posted comment will appear after it has been approved.
Frequently asked questions about story commenting.
(optional)
   
M wrote on January 13, 2008 12:11 am:
" Such a short life. Forgotten when it mattered most. Never to be forgotten again. Thank you Cindy for your wonderful yet sad story. "

hurts my heart wrote on January 13, 2008 7:20 am:
" I will change the way I interact with my neighbors, my family, my friends. Thank you Zeke. I don't live in your community but I am so sorry we (fellow human beings) let you down. "

Dave wrote on January 13, 2008 8:00 am:
" Good article Cindy,it makes you stop and think about the difference between living in a small town like my wife and I do, and living in a large city where you get lost and no one notices. "

Rachel wrote on January 13, 2008 9:32 am:
" .. and once again you have brought the tears to my eyes and the truth of society that we all refuse to accept .. "

A Mom wrote on January 13, 2008 10:27 am:
" Amen. "

saddened! wrote on January 13, 2008 11:42 am:
" This is truly one of the saddest stories that I have ever heard and to think that this little baby was left to his own, is disgusting! Where the h**l were the family and the friends and the nosy neighbors, anybody! The mailman who had to see the mail wasn't getting picked up! How totally awful that this mommy and her baby were so forgotten by society that no one even noticed they weren't around anymore. I would have. I say Hi to my neighbors, even though I don't know their names. Where was the family? So what, she distanced herself, can't they still pick up the phone and say Hi or stop by and bring the Christmas present they bought for the baby? Just so much and so many "what if"'s. Just what if?? "

rukiddingme? wrote on January 13, 2008 12:45 pm:
" Thanks Cindy, another well written article that makes me think...and cry. And yes, we are all slightly to blame. May God bless this child and his mother. "

ac wrote on January 13, 2008 12:51 pm:
" This story is one of the saddest I've ever heard. People need to connect. Soneone needs to care. When our daughter rented an apt. online, and moved to the Twin Cities, I worried about her. She didn't know a soul there, but she did have a job. Being a runner, I worried that if something happened to her while out running, no one would miss her until she didn't show up for work.

Don't we know when our neighbors come and go? Didn't someone notice the quietness or the mail not being picked up?? It is so sad, when family members disconnect themselves from each other. Isn't that part of being a family???? We always have someone that cares about us??? That baby did not deserve to die that way! "

wondering wrote on January 13, 2008 1:52 pm:
" What a tragic, wrenching story. Perhaps the best New Years resolution we could all make is to slow down and take note of those around us. "

One of many wrote on January 13, 2008 4:15 pm:
" Many stories like this are waiting to be written. So what is the solution? What can be done? That is the real story. "

pam wrote on January 13, 2008 5:25 pm:
" how very sad and tragic. maybe this can be a reminder to pay a little attention to our surroundings. don't hesitate to call the police if something seems amiss-it may save a life. rest in peace zeke and mom. "

georgie wrote on January 13, 2008 8:44 pm:
" i'll never feel embarassed again about checking up on a neighbor when i hear sirens or when the paper is piled up for a couple days or worrying for a little bit and calling up my parents when they don't play scrabble on-line with me for a day or two! this story is sad beyond sad beyond sad. we are humanity are forgetting ourselves... "

Good Job Cindy wrote on January 13, 2008 9:17 pm:
" I've got to hand it to you Cindy, this is probably one of the few well done stories you have published. This pair deserves our prayers, pray for their lives in purgatory. May they both soon be surrounded by our Father. "

Ripper wrote on January 13, 2008 10:08 pm:
" I served in Vietnam, I have seen death first hand, have participated in creating death and have had death visit close to me. Never shed a tear-when I read about Ezekiel and his mother I shed tears. When I read your article today-I shed tears again. Today, I introduced myself to the little old lady that lives two doors down. Tomorrow, I will canvas my neigborhood and make sure nobody ever suffers this fate. "

kw wrote on January 14, 2008 5:34 am:
" You are wrong when you say that people who live in small towns know their neighbors....I have lived in the same home for 42 years, and I do not know most of mine. They come and go and they don't want to "visit over the backyard fence". I wrote last week that we should care about our neighbors and check on them if we don't see them out and about. Someone had to have heard that little guy cry...I just don't believe this had to happen..all the neighbors and her family, especially, should be ashamed of themselves. I know little Zeke is sitting in the arms of his Savior and is at peace. "

Jan wrote on January 14, 2008 6:52 am:
" What a sad story. EVERYONE let them down, family, friends, co-workers, service people, etc. Thanks, Cindy, for bringing this to our attention and reminding us that we all have responsibility for our fellow human beings. We need to be reminded "If you did it to the least of these, my brethren, you did it to me". "

LR wrote on January 14, 2008 7:00 am:
" I read this article in yesterday's paper and like many others who have posted here, it made me weep. Your words ring true, Cindy.... In a city of half-million people, how can this happen? Change starts with one person. I intend to be one such person in my neighborhood. "

Sally Herrin wrote on January 14, 2008 7:39 am:
" Thanks, Cindy, for giving voice to the thoughts that have been chewing on my heart since I read about this child's death. "

Jennifer wrote on January 14, 2008 9:23 am:
" How very, very sad that this child and his mother were so all alone in this world that no one missed them or no one noticed they weren't around. It makes you stop and think that we should value our family and look out for one another.

Thank you Cindy, you told this story like no one else could with humanity and compassion. "

Ang wrote on January 14, 2008 10:05 am:
" I can't stop thinking about this story. I have an 18 month old boy, with blonde hair like little Zeke, and I just keep hugging and kissing him, thinking about that little sweet boy all alone. This is why it is hard for me to believe that there is a God looking down on us, where were his guardian angels and the God that should have not let this happen? All of the people commenting are good and wonderful, I wish ALL people were just like all of us out there, looking and wanting the help those in need. "

Grundle wrote on January 14, 2008 11:19 am:
" Such a sad story, especially when you consider the ways this death should have been prevented. Unfortunately, I fear this is a product of apartment living. As someone who has lived in an apartment for 4 years, I can't say that I've ever gotten to know any of my neighbors. It's a nice complex, and the management makes half-hearted attempts to build something that resembles a community, but the reality is that people come and go. Your neighbors change...often without ever knowing they're gone. On top of that, apartment neighbors often do things that make others avoid them. Quite often, I've found myself extremely annoyed with my neighbors for a littany of reasons...having their stereo on full-blast, loudly expressing the throws of their passion, getting into domestic disputes, their cigarette smoke entering through my patio door, and drunk neighbors coming home and pressing all of the intercom alarm buttons. When it comes down to it, I don't necessarily WANT to know any of my neighbors. In this particular case, I would imagine that the neighbors had become accustomed to hearing a baby cry, because that's what babies do. Simply hearing the baby crying wouldn't necessarily suggest that something was amiss. In addition, very rarely do I actually see any of my neighbors coming and going, so I wouldn't be able to say that anything was out of the ordinary, especially if I have no idea of what their schedule is, or if they've gone on vacation, or moved out. I don't think it's fair to say that society is to blame for this. How far are we supposed to take the notion of knowing and interacting with all of our neighbors? I already have enough friends, and don't think I need more, especially not 15-20 more. I think this comes down to those who supposedly loved these two failing them. The father of the child apparently had no interest in seeing his son. And her family, wherever they may be, didn't appear to concerned over her absence during Christmas. We can't continue to blame society for the shortcomings of individuals. I don't want to assign blame to anyone in this tragic case. I'm just afraid that, for better or for worse (obviously in this case, worse), this is the way things are. "

Anon wrote on January 14, 2008 11:22 am:
" Yes, there are those of us without friends or family. That doesn't have to be a sad thing. Yes, there are a lot of people in this state who never look outside their own group of friends. There are a lot of cold people as well. If I disappear, I certainy don't expect anyone to notice, and that's not anyone's fault. The mailman might think I'm on vacation. It's ok to be alone--it does not have to mean unhappiness. "

thank you wrote on January 14, 2008 1:18 pm:
" thanks for writing about this issue. this is absolutely horrible. as a mother i could not even imagine my son dying a slow horrible death because no one came to help or thought to look out for their surroundings. i hope people really think about this and learn from it. rest in peace. "

another mother wrote on January 14, 2008 1:29 pm:
" once again, this story has made me cry. I would like to think that Zeke's mom was there with him the whole time waiting and watching over him. So, i do hope he didnt die totally alone. Maybe this should teach all of us to care for our neighbor no matter who they are. "

Douglas wrote on January 14, 2008 2:07 pm:
" Poor little Zeke didn't choose the life he had but his mother did and risked his life too. How can anybody become so isolated they have no conistant contact with another human that would miss them in these circumstances. "

Crying wrote on January 14, 2008 2:07 pm:
" oh that poor child oh that poor family this story has disturbed me since i first heard it oh i can't stand how small it makes me feel to know a little child had to suffer so and no one knew it "

Jon in Long Beach wrote on January 14, 2008 3:29 pm:
" “City life is millions of people being lonesome together.” Henry David Thoreau wrote these words before the advent of the suburbs in the 1950s. Today, suburban life is millions of people being alone with their families because isolated there they can be safe from the city and not have to contribute anything, other than tax dollars, to making the cities of America better places to live. It takes a village.
"

SAD DOESNT EVEN DO IT wrote on January 14, 2008 3:52 pm:
" I keep thinking about when this story first came out, and I saw on the news the aunt of this little boy saying how she never "got around" to meeting him. She wanted people to feel sorry for her loss, but I just can't. I have the deepest sadness for what this little boy went through, but for the aunts uncles etc .... don't ask for empathy when you didnt care about this child for 21 months. "

Dano wrote on January 14, 2008 4:11 pm:
" I pray for the family and people close that failed these two. They will suffer ong after we have buried this story in our minds and hearts. They will have to live with this until their end of time. I hope and pray, that while rasing my own family, I have taught them to care for more than themselves, but for everyone. I still can't understand that how or why, and I am not sure we ever will. This is very sad, very depressing. I truly hope they are together in a better place. "

Joan wrote on January 14, 2008 11:12 pm:
" To the family of Ms. browning I say "How can you sit there crying and saying you will miss her & Zeke" You didnt know them & evidently didnt have any feelings for Zeke or you would have "found the time in 21 months" to go visit him at some time. How busy can you be? God is with both Mom & baby now. I know this in my heart! "

Georgia wrote on January 15, 2008 7:07 am:
" I am sending this article to everyone I know. We are a society who is too busy with our own life and problems to take care of our own...I vow to never be that busy from this moment on....Shame on our society! "

Luanne wrote on January 15, 2008 10:03 am:
" This is only one case of family neglect. Where has humanitarianism gone. Even if you are not a Christian, a lot could be changed by living by the ten commandments. The Golden rule is a pretty good one too. Everyone needs to seriously think about death without anyone who cares--deeply explore this in your souls. We will all die one day--I want someone with me and to have made things right with the world. "

kcm wrote on January 22, 2008 7:36 pm:
" I was very disappointed to read the comments of one reader who claims this woman "chose" isolation and risked her son's life. Every time you judge someone and marginalize them, you create this very situation. Is it okay that people suffer and die as long as we feel justified in blaming them for it?

"They also will answer, 'Lord, when did we see you hungry or thirsty or a stranger or needing clothes or sick or in prison, and did not help you?' He will reply, 'I tell you the truth, whatever you did not do for one of the least of these, you did not do for me.'" Matthew 25: 44-45 "

cop wrote on January 25, 2008 6:58 pm:
" I've worked in Law Enforcement many years..and every day see the disconnect in our society, nobody knows their neighbors any more. Thanks Cindy for this article, your words helped me cope with this story that I just can't get out of my head. Sad. "