Now
Fair
38°
High
51°
Low
29°

A year later, accident victim still struggles

Text Size: 
Tools Sponsor

BY HILARY KINDSCHUH / Lincoln Journal Star

Thursday, Nov 15, 2007 - 12:12:17 am CST

I hear them talking about me, but I can’t say anything.

“It’s kind of amazing how fast your life can change in one second, huh, Jena?” my mom says. “One second, your life is changed.”

Several moments pass, and my mom, my grandma and my Aunt Dana are silent.

Story Photo
Wearing a shirt with Jena's picture on it, Debbie moisturizes her daughter's lips. (Robert Becker)

Related Media

A mother's faith, a daughter's rough road ahead

Deb Chinnow, the mother of Jena Van Groningen, has never given up hope that her daughter will be walking and talking again some day. Jena has a traum...

How to help

There will be a fundraiser for Jena Van Groningen at 7 p.m. Friday at the Isles Reception Hall, 6232 Havelock Ave.

There will be food, a silent auction, a cash bar and live music.

The family would like to use the funds to purchase a stairway lift so Jena will be able to get down to the basement at the new house.

Make checks payable to Jena Van Groningen.

Check on progress

To check on Jena Van Groningen’s progress, go to www.carepages.com and set up an account.

To visit Jena’s page, type Jenastarstrutter (one word) into the “Visit a CarePage” box.

“Oh, I shouldn’t have said that,” Mom says, breaking the pause. “Makes you want to cry.”

 I feel her pat my knee.

“It’s kind of funny, because people say, ‘It’s just not fair,’ and I’m like, ‘Well you know, it isn’t … but who said life was ever fair?’” she says. “Life isn’t fair, is it, Jena?”

In three days it will be the one-year anniversary of the day that changed our lives.

Since that day, I’ve been in a coma, unable to speak to anyone.

“We’ll get through it, won’t we, Jenny?” Mom says, sitting on my bed to face me. “One more day that we have you, I guess, we could look at it that way.

“(Because) one point in time we were making funeral arrangements.”

No one knows if Jena Van Groningen can hear her mother’s words, feel her mother pat her knee. No one knows if, or to what degree, she is aware of her surroundings.

Last year at this time, the 2006 graduate of Lincoln Northeast High School had just begun classes at Southeast Community College and was considering a career in medicine.

Then 18, she was hit by a police cruiser at 12:28 a.m. on Nov. 5, 2006, as she and some friends crossed South 48th Street between Bryson and C streets.

Lincoln Police Officer Amanda May, then 26, was answering a call for backup at a home near Sheridan Boulevard and Van Dorn Street when Jena stepped in front of the cruiser.

In addition to a massive traumatic brain injury, Jena suffered a broken pelvis and other broken bones, as well as injuries to her spine and spleen.

She was in the intensive care unit at BryanLGH Medical Center West until Nov. 22, when she was transferred to Madonna Rehabilitation Hospital.

On Jan. 19, Jena was moved to Quality Living Inc. in Omaha, where she remained until May 25.

Since then, Jena and her mom, Debbie Chinnow, have been living with Chinnow’s parents in Plattsmouth. Chinnow’s sister, Dana Torres, also has a hospital bed for Jena at her home in Plattsmouth.

Jena’s grandfather, Norman Sunderman, is building a handicap-accessible house nearby, and her mom recently became a certified nursing assistant.

“We haven’t left the child’s side for 24/7, between me and my mom and my sister,” Chinnow said. “I would not be able to do this without the help of my family.”

Jena’s father, Kim Van Groningen, lives nearby in Lincoln.

The family always knew they would take Jena home, but it took a long time — especially considering the beginning.

Seven days after she was hurt, Jena’s family had just begun to think she was out of the woods when “everything just started going from bad to worse,” her mother said.

A doctor told them they needed to decide between two operations, a craniotomy or a stent, to reduce the swelling in Jena’s brain.

In a craniotomy, a piece of the skull is removed to allow the brain to expand. With a stent, doctors insert a tube into the ventricles of the brain to drain fluid.

“He said we needed to do (something) immediately, if not sooner,” Chinnow recalled. “We’re just stunned, you know? We’re not the doctors, we didn’t know.

“So I just said to this doctor, ‘If it was your daughter, what would you do?’

“And he said, ‘remove the bone flap.’ He did not even hesitate.”

Doctors did the craniotomy and later told Jena’s family that when they removed the bone flap, her brain popped out like a balloon.

And she still wasn’t out of the woods.

One of the emergency room workers told her family she probably wouldn’t make it through the night.

Jena’s mother, grandmother and aunt are gathered around Jena’s hospital bed in the living room, quiet as they remember that night. Tears come to their eyes.

“It was amazing, that night when they said that, we had people lined up for miles at the hospital to see her,” Chinnow says, her voice breaking. “And she was a tough little fart.”

She looks away, making a sound somewhere between a sob and a laugh.

“I shouldn’t have said that — who brought that up?”

She gets off her daughter’s bed to grab a tissue.

“We definitely don’t talk about losing her,” says Jena’s aunt, Dana Torres.

Jena’s family is glad they never had to make a decision about whether to keep her alive or let her go.

Doctors almost had to resuscitate her once. Should it happen again, they asked later, did the family want them to resuscitate?

Her mom didn’t have to think twice.

“That’s such a young life — I just feel like they’re a lot stronger,” Chinnow says. “It would be different if she was 60 or 70 years old.

“But being 18 at the time — absolutely, resuscitate that child.”

Jena flew about 35 feet when she was hit by that car. When the doctor was going through Jena’s CAT scan, Chinnow said, “she had so many bruises throughout her brain that he couldn’t count them all.”

Right now, Jena is at a Cognitive Level III on the Rancho Levels of Cognitive Functioning scale.

That means she may be awake on and off and react more specifically to what she sees, hears or feels, according to the Rancho Los Amigos National Rehabilitation Center.

For example, a person at Level III might turn toward a sound, withdraw from pain and try to watch a person move around the room.

A Level III may begin to recognize family and friends, start to follow such simple directions as “look at me” or “squeeze my hand” and begin to respond to simple questions by nodding the head.

Reaction, however, can be slow and inconsistent.

Because of a lawsuit filed on behalf of Chinnow against the city of Lincoln and Officer May, who resigned earlier this year, the family’s attorney, David A. Domina of Omaha, recommended that Jena’s family not allow her doctors to discuss her condition and outlook.

Dr. Peter Lennarson, a neurosurgeon at the University of Nebraska Medical Center, said different factors often combine to create a condition like Jena’s.

“A craniotomy lowers (brain pressure) instantly, but it doesn’t fix the underlying problem that was causing the swelling and high pressure,” he said. “A defect created by surgery can further injure brain cells.

“It’s not as simple as it might sound — it’s a last-resort treatment.”

Lennarson, who has performed craniotomies on injured soldiers in Iraq, couldn’t speak more specifically about Jena’s condition and outlook because he is not one of her doctors. But he said he would have hoped to see more progress at this point.

“Most of the dramatic improvements we see are within the first year, year and a half,” he said. “I think the chances honestly of her having a significant improvement at this point (are) small, but not impossible.”

Doctors have told Jena’s family she probably will never wake up. “But they told us (she wouldn’t do) so many things, and she’s doing it. … You’ve just got to think, it’s in (God’s) hands, and he’s got a big plan,” Chinnow says.

Doctors also said Jena probably wouldn’t be able to breathe on her own; she is.

She also can move her arms and legs and head.

“When he’s ready to wake her up, she’s going to wake up,” Chinnow says. “We kind of ask him every day, ‘What are you waiting for?’

“But you know, his timing is a little different than ours.”

Chinnow looks at her daughter.

“Regretfully, huh?”

Jena’s family took her camping in Missouri over Memorial Day weekend.

“(People think) sometimes that we’re crazy because we take her everywhere,” her mother says.

She sits at the end of her daughter’s bed, holding Jena’s left foot.

“I just feel like, you know, she’s still got to have something in life, so we just take her everywhere.”

Later, Jena opens her eyes and watches her grandmother, Hazel Sunderman, who has begun to hook up her feeding tube.

“We’re going to have her walking and talking someday,” Chinnow says. “I’m never going to give up on that.”

Since the accident, Jena’s family has been in contact with the families of other brain injury patients.

“Some of the people who’ve written to us, when (doctors) told us that Jena is probably never going to wake up, they said, ‘Ugh, do not believe that.’ And I wouldn’t anyways,” Chinnow says.

Jena opens her eyes again as Sunderman strokes her hair and takes her hand.

Those other families said doctors told them their child would never walk or talk again. Happily, those doctors were proven wrong.

“It sounded like what Jena went through was exactly what their child had gone through,” Chinnow says. “And some of them worse.”

Jena is more minimally conscious than she is in a coma because she hears and understands things, says her grandmother.

“If you make a noise, she hears you,” Sunderman says.

Chinnow claps, and Jena briefly opens her eyes.

“She knows what we’re saying,” Sunderman continues. “I talk to her, like I tell her, ‘Your dad’s coming.’”

Chinnow steps closer to her daughter and taps her on the shoulder.

Jena’s eyes pop open and look in her mom’s direction, and she moves her head slightly.

“See how she knows when you’re touching her?” Sunderman asks.

Chinnow, still at her daughter’s side, says Jena’s name.

“If there’s a loud noise … if someone coughs, she turns to look, like, ‘What’s going on?’” Sunderman says.

Chinnow leans in and kisses her daughter’s cheek.

The corners of Jena’s mouth turn up ever so slightly.

Reach Hilary Kindschuh at 473-7120 or hkindschuh@journalstar.com.


$1 Sunday Delivery - Subscribe Today!
Local > Back to Top of Story

All posts to JournalStar.com are subject to our Terms and Standards.
Your posted comment will appear after it has been approved.
Frequently asked questions about story commenting.
(optional)
   
Nathan Biggs wrote on November 15, 2007 5:12 am:
" What was she doing walking that time of night? Why did she not look before stepping out in front of the car? I suppose they blame the cop who hit her. Pretty sad. "

Doug wrote on November 15, 2007 6:21 am:
" When a Doctor tells you the future you must remember he is talking about averages. The challenge is to give her better than average care, better than average stimulation, and better than average faith in prayer. God will give her and the family the best possible outcome. His perspective is eternal life without the body we have at this time. For eternal life do you suppose we get a new physical body or are freed from the inconvenience of needing one at all? "

JJ wrote on November 15, 2007 7:07 am:
" Why is this family suing? I thought the girl was crossing illegally and the officer was going to a call? I don't think that is the fault of the officer. I send my best to Jena & her family. "

sad wrote on November 15, 2007 7:20 am:
" What a sad story. It fails to mention what Jena and her friends were doing at 12:30AM walking across Sheridan. Why didn't they hear or see the cruiser coming? Were they intoxicated? Any culpability on her and her friends part? Just asking, since it's not mentioned here. It's too bad the city is now facing a lawsuit when an officer was just doing her job. "

Stay strong.. wrote on November 15, 2007 8:06 am:
" and keep believing that God's time is to come. How blessed this young girl is to have a family who didn't just turn her over to a nursing home. I'll also pray for fromer officer May. I don't kow anything about her, but I've got to believe that she also needs all of our prayers to help her work through all of this. Sad to say that sometimes accidents happen, but this accident did happen and we need to live one day at a time and pray for the best for all. "

Avg Lincoln Taxpayer-Taxed To Death wrote on November 15, 2007 8:48 am:
" Such a heart breaking story. I would hate to wish this upon my worst enemy. I wish to tell the family and friends of Jena that their pains are shared with this community of Lincoln, and beyond. God Bless... "

Nina wrote on November 15, 2007 8:57 am:
" My son taught this girl in high school. Blessings to Jena and all her family as they struggle with this devastating situation. Regardless of how much she recovers, she and her family both benefit from the dedication shown to care for her, and the attempts to communicate. We will pray for progress for Jena and others in similar situations, that they may have life abundantly once again. "

AD - share story with your kids wrote on November 15, 2007 9:27 am:
" I hope parents share this story with their teenager/young adult children....silly/fun actions can have consequences that alter your life forever. How unfortuanate for this child/family! Bad things happen to good people, I hope the family can loose the misplaced blame and move on. I hope Jena can recover a quality of life worth living. "

OMG.... wrote on November 15, 2007 9:50 am:
" Nathan....she is 18, it was only 12:30 at night. Most kids that age dont have to be home till 1! She was with friends, it was not like she was out walking by herself.. You can not tell me that you were never out at that time of day when you were 18. Lets think about her and her family...look at what they are going through and how much their lives have changed forever!!! Why must we always blame and talk bad about people. This story is about Jena, her family and the life that they are going to have to come acustom too...not the officer and what the girl was doing....What would you do if this happend to you or someone in your family? AS for Jena and her family....GOD BLESS YOU! stay strong and believe in the power of prayer.... "

Donna wrote on November 15, 2007 10:02 am:
" Yes the cruiser was enroute to a call. However, they didn't hear the cruiser coming because the cruiser did not have either its siren or flashing lights engaged. And I'm sorry, but does that make any of this any less tragic? I don't think so. "

Sad story wrote on November 15, 2007 10:17 am:
" Hope they come to their senses and drop the bogus lawsuit, though. Only hurt the taxpayers and the officer, who was only attempting to do her job. "

AG wrote on November 15, 2007 10:21 am:
" I understand the comments about the officer going to a call. However, keep in mind there are times that police respond to calls without sirens/lights. This often happens when responding to potentially dangerous situations like domestic violence. The police don't want to increase the danger if the suspect hears sirens or sees lights. Officer May could have been responding in such a manner, and then there would have been no lights or sirens for Jena to see. Jena could have thought she had enough time to cross if she didn't realize the rate of speed the officer was travelling. The story isn't clear on these issues, so to presume anyone is at fault is somewhat premature. Let's wait for the full information about the specifics of the accident before casting aspersions on either Officer May or on Jena. My best wishes and prayers for strength go out to Jena, her family, and the officer. "

LTR wrote on November 15, 2007 10:29 am:
" This is obviously a tragic story. Not only because Jena and friends should have been home and not out at that time, but Jena's poor decision has cost a good police officer her job, her career and her dreams. I regret the way in which the LJS portrays this tragedy. This ought be a message to all parents of teenagers and all teens. Jena's decision has long term ramifications for many others as well. LJS, Officer May's life has a tragic outcome as well. Of course in this day and time no one seems able to accept responsibility for their decisions. Yeah, sue the police who daily risk life for our safety. Makes sense to me? "

Another Mom wrote on November 15, 2007 10:30 am:
" Many blessings and prayers to Jena's family. If you have any recollection or have read articles pertaining to Jena, you wouldn't be placing all the blame on her. The officer did NOT have her lights on, nor her sirens. Witnesses stated that the car was over a block away when the girls crossed the street. However, the officer was traveling a high rate of speed - in fact well over the posted speed limit. So before you blame the child - remember, there are two sides to this story. "

JM wrote on November 15, 2007 10:36 am:
" why is it that when theres a tragedy, all people do is blame the "teenager who was walking across the street illegally?" She is never going to be the same again. No one deserves that. "

kcbob wrote on November 15, 2007 10:55 am:
" How sad. My prayers to Jena and her family. She was 18....she can be out when ever she wants. As to why she did not see the cop car...I don't know, not enough informaion in this story. Maybe more informaion will come out at trial. Maybe the cop car did not have lights and sirens blaring...who knows. Bottom line. This person needs prayers...not questions. God bless. "

No Flashin Lights wrote on November 15, 2007 11:05 am:
" I'm sure nobody blames the officer personally for doing her job, but didn't the news report that the cruiser was speeding without it's flashing lights on? It was a terrible accident but I can't help but think if the officer had her lights flashing and siren on, it likely wouldn't have happened. "

You people wrote on November 15, 2007 12:01 pm:
" Who cares about the facts of this accident that happened a year ago...that is NOT what this story is about....it is about Jena and what she is going thru and how she is doing. IF you all want a story about the"hell" the PO is going thru..go aheaf write one..I wanna see the comments on that one!!...Think about it...what if this was you or your family...i dont think that you would all be trash talking them...now would you! "

NL wrote on November 15, 2007 12:29 pm:
" The reason LJS didn't print all about the accident was because the article is about Jena, and her daily living. I hope God hear's your prayers, I've been hoping for a miracle myself, so I know how desperately you want life to be normal again. Peace to Jena. "

WOW wrote on November 15, 2007 12:30 pm:
" I cant believe people can read this story and see the pictures of this poor girl and say the horrible things you all say. Does it really matter how it happened people?? For all you bitter no hearted people, What if this was your child?? "

MRS wrote on November 15, 2007 12:38 pm:
" It was that, nothing more than a horrible accident. I know this girl and her mother, and they or no one else for that matter deserves to go through something like this. I don't know the officer but also know that it has to be just as horrible for her. But as Deb says, there is a reason that things happen like this and God has a plan for everyone. So instead of writing about who is to blame, why not trying to say a prayer for EVERYONE who is involved. "

Christine wrote on November 15, 2007 12:44 pm:
" God bless you and Jena! I have a daughter Jena's age, I can't imagine what your going through. I will pray for your family to have strenght and Jena to wake up and live a full life. Don't give up she will thank you some day. "

Riddick51PB wrote on November 15, 2007 12:55 pm:
" it's generally good policy to look both ways before entering a lane where a car can mow you down. that's true whether you're walking, driving a car, or riding a bicycle. that goes for whether it's daytime or night. "

tl wrote on November 15, 2007 1:03 pm:
" Guess what? Good kids are out past midnight! This is a heartbreaking story for both Jena and May. both of their lives are changed forever. Now stop pointing fingers Nebraska and be the community we pride ourselves on. "

Pathetic wrote on November 15, 2007 1:06 pm:
" Wow. I'm amazed at how hateful, once again, people are when a tragic thing happens. Don't chastise, don't hate Jena, nor the police officer. This family will need the financial help to pay for current and future medical bills. I'm in shock. I say to the family, great job loving your daughter, to the officer, keep strong, to everyone else, we all make mistakes. This was an ACCIDENT and two people are suffering. I can't stop shaking my head at the comment Nathan wrote. No sympathy for Jena, just blame. We should all stay in our homes, never walk outside, and we will be safe huh? When is the proper and correct time to leave our homes and cross a street? "

JSM wrote on November 15, 2007 1:57 pm:
" I'm really appalled by some of these comments. Sitting here from our armchairs trying to lay blame for a horrific accident, it is easy to fire-off any darn thing that comes to mind-but we don't know. The article is about a family's love for their child-how devoid of human emotion do you need to be that it feels appropriate to spew the sort of rubbish I'm reading here? Where on earth do people learn to behave this way? Talk radio? Maybe instead of sharing these oh-so-informed opinions, you could take a minute and say a prayer for this child and her family. And while we're at it-let's say a few prayers for our community because obviously, something is very sick and broken in this town that we feel the need to chastise a girl with brain damage. "

Medical Costs wrote on November 15, 2007 2:09 pm:
" Keep in mind the family may not have enough money to pay the medical bills and are forced to sue to cover them. In a case like this the medical bills are ongoing for an unknown amount of time. They may have no other option. Put yourself in their place. From many of the asinine comments on this article it seems to be a real problem for you Lincolnites to do that. "

A friend wrote on November 15, 2007 2:34 pm:
" Its pretty sad that we have to have negative and rude comments when this poor girl lies in a bed unable to move.Insead of rude comments, how about say a few prayers and hope someday it does not come back to bite you in the butt!!!!!! This girl has never hurt anyone in her life.She is the most caring person ever. She would be devasated at some of these articles.What I have heard is that the police had to be investigated by internal affairs because they messed it up. We will see when this goes to court.God Bless Jena and her family!!!!! "

It was an accident wrote on November 15, 2007 3:04 pm:
" I'm 34 reading this makes me get teary eyed, trust me when I say, I'm not a guy that gets emotional. But this was an accident- the officer was trying to protect- this was her job. This girl was doing what most of us did when we were 18- trying to have a good time. I just pray that something like this never happens to my daughter- it's a horrible thing for everyone involved. "

how sad... wrote on November 15, 2007 3:26 pm:
" I'm sure this family would drop the lawsuit in a heartbeat if they could have their daughter back. This lawsuit is necessary in order to afford the $900,000 in medical bills that have accumulated in the last year. These bills are not going to stop coming in for the time being. This has been an unfortunate life changing experience for Jena and her family. You people with your hateful comments need to put yourself in their shoes before you write your jibberish. "

Good Friend wrote on November 15, 2007 3:28 pm:
" It is so unbelievable that people who have no idea about the whole situation, an sit here on the computer and make such rude and inappropriate comments about Jena,and her family for that matter. I have known Jena since we were eleven or twelve years old. She is one of my best friends.Jena was Prom Queen, played golf, was on the dance team with myself and many other girls.No matter what the circumstanes were, where are peoples hearts at? This could have been anyones child, or even you. Who would you be blaming? How many people our age do go out and dont come home early? I guarantee over half the people that have made comments on here stayed out late with their friends. She was almost 19 years old and almost Considered an adult.Please...how many of you go to the bars on the weekends and get wasted, and drive home. Think of all the lives you risk? THis officer i'm sure feels horrible.It is hard to see both sides,yes. But she didnt have her sirens or lights on going 45 mph over a hill. a neighbor close by even says the firetrucks and ambulance fly through there too. There are many stories out there that may be similar or completely different. But either way I think that someone who has came this far, has gone through this much, deserves a little piece of our thoughts and prayers. I think and pray about Jena everyday. I know that there are many people out there who think just the same! For all of you who are thinking of Jena and have the place in your heart for her God Bless you. All of her family and friends need all the help they can get to get the big guy to wake her up. We all love her and pray that he will do what is best. Why waste my time worrying about what all of you think? all i care about is that whatever happens is for the best. And Nathan its also pretty sad that you have no heart. What if this happened to you?...think about someone besides yourself and rude opinions.and they werent walking across sheridan. If you dont know the story dont make comments. I pray for you people who are like this.. "

Mother of 3 wrote on November 15, 2007 4:01 pm:
" If this would have been one of my children I would be sueing the city also. The expenses to take care of their child have to be out of this world. Who should have to pay for this? Most health insurance companies have a maxium amount they will pay and sometimes they won't pay if it caused by a accident. I know the police have a job to do but they also need to be held responsible for their actions. They need to find a way to travel to a call safely. How could this girl know that the police officer was traveling at high speeds. She may have thought she had plenty of time to cross the street. If the officer would have had the lights on the car it would have alerted the kids that this was the police and they were headed to a call. She could have turned the lights off before she arrived in area. My heart goes out to all the parties involved. This is a terrible accident. "

Accident wrote on November 15, 2007 4:40 pm:
" Underage drinkers crossing a busy street late at night… an officer doing her job... resulting in severe injury and the end of a woman’s career--accidents happen. It could have been anyone’s vehicle Jena stepped in front of that night. My thoughts and prayers are with Jena, Amanda, and their families. "

SF wrote on November 15, 2007 5:24 pm:
" Why sue the officer. Why ruin her life as well. I'm sure she's sick about what happened, and has to live with that every day of her life. Oh, but thats right, we live in a society where we just sue everyone because something happens we don't like. Bad things happen, thats unfortunately a sad fact of life. Ruining someone elses life won't change things. But we always have to blame someone don't we. No doubt the family will have a huge financial burden, its too bad the city can't admit fault and offer some sort of compensation. Oh, but thats right, we're dealing with lawyers here. The lawyer who wants a big payoff on the suit, and the lawyer who is defending the city. "

policegirl wrote on November 15, 2007 6:29 pm:
" If this accident didn't involve a police officer, nobody would hear anything about it. From what I understand, the police officer didn't do anything out of the ordinary, wrongly, or outside of procedure. They don't ALWAYS run with their lights and sirens on. I feel bad for Jena and her family, but let's be realistic on who we're angry with and why. If she had stepped out in front of a regular non-police person, nobody would have heard anything about this. We always look for someone to blame. Maybe the culpability doesn't just lie with the PD. "

Good grief wrote on November 15, 2007 9:52 pm:
" I live in the middle of the block. If I need to go across the street to visit my neighbor, I look both ways then cross the street. I don't, nor do I believe many of you do either, go to the end of the block and use the cross walk. These kids looked, saw a car approaching and felt they had ample time to cross. There was no indication/alert that the car approaching was at high speeds. To the LPD, I value your service and respect your need to speed for an emergency. BUT, when you accelerate your speed, I expect you to have your eyes on the road, prepared for any person/pet/object to cross your path and make your presence known if indeed I am in your path. When Officer May responded to a call to serve and protect (those in the domestic violence), she failed to serve and protect others along the way (Jena). It truly is an unfortunate accident, something both parties have to live with the consequences for the rest of their lives. Both parties do need our prayers for healing, physical & emotional. (Maybe we should blame those in the domestic violence act. If it wasn't for their irrational behavior, Officer May wouldn't have been speeding!). You need to watch the LJS video of Jena & her Mom...what inspiration and hope! Debbie, thank you for your role model of being positive and loving your daughter. What an example for us! God will provide your needs! "

Megan wrote on November 16, 2007 2:49 am:
" Sadly, I think people have missed the true meaning of this article… This is a story about a mother standing at the bedside of her child, one of two victims of a terrible tragedy. This is a story of the FAITH and COURAGE that should be inspiring to our community. Instead, a few people have taken this as an opportunity to voice their unfair, insensitive and ignorant opinions. I encourage you all to not only pray for Jena, her family and the police officer involved, but to pray for these sad individuals…their souls depend on it. "

DJ wrote on November 16, 2007 5:58 am:
" AG is right, when there is a domestic violence situation, the officers will not use lights or sirens because it puts the potential victim in more danger. It was an unfortunate accident, and I hope everything gets better, but don't blame the officer doing her job. "

Dana wrote on November 16, 2007 7:03 am:
" Pedestrians have the right of way even when they are crossing illegally, and the officer should have been paying attention. Any one of us would be sued as well. You have to watch for people when you are in a car, even people who are not crossing legally, because between a human and a car, the car always wins. So of course her family is suing... They would sue me if I hit there J-walking child... if she was really crossing illegally. Also, I didn't live with my parents at the age of 18. in most states that is the age of a legal adult. she can vote, she has no legal curfue here, she went out with friends. 1230 is a perfectly age appropriate time to be out. I have compassion for the officer. That would be very hard, but her family has every right to sue, even if they don't win. That is what the legal system is for. The family is flipping the bill on this one both emotionally and financially, and if it is ruled in court that someone else should pay, that is only fair. Everyone involved should be in our prayers. "

False Info wrote on November 16, 2007 7:41 am:
" All these comments about Jena drinking?? Where did they come from?? There has never been any information saying that she was drinking. She is a good girl who was out with friends. She was not drinking at the time of the accident. It is a shame that we blame a young girl for protocols not followed by a police officer. This family has had to sell there house, hold continuous benefits, and rely on donations to pay the accumulating bills. Who should pay for all of this?? Yes, it was an accident but somebody has to help the family. I think if you don't know all of the facts, or only have hateful things to say, you probably shouldn't voice your opinion. Let's focus on Jena and the tremendous strength her family has had in the unbelievable tradgedy. "

Krc1995 wrote on November 16, 2007 8:06 am:
" Horrbile and heartbreaking. If I knew where to send money, I would. BUT, did Officer May quite because of this? From reading the acticle, it sounds like much of the responsibility lies with Jena and her friends. I wish the family wouldn't sue if that were the case. Then again, anyone can sue and I think it is expected if your a police officer that you may be involved in situations that may produce lawsuits. Officer May didn't have the thick skin necessary to be a police officer if this is the case. I am sure, for legal purposes, that not all the facts were published in this article "

Mike White wrote on November 16, 2007 8:28 am:
" Have you ever heard of a cop involved in an accident, "NOT GOING" on an emergency police call ?????, Cops blow stop signs, run red lights, make U turns and in general violate driving laws on a regular basis, when they get caught or have an accident their standard excuse is what? That's right, they were going on a police call, they just forgot to tell you it was a call to the donut shop with their cop buddies. O.M.G, give these poor people the benefit of the doubt and support them in there time of need. "

Anyone Notice wrote on November 16, 2007 8:39 am:
" Did anyone notice that Amanda May is now a Deputy for Gage County and is the interim jail administrator since Jeremy Wach's death....therefore this incident DID NOT end her career as stated... "

I care too wrote on November 16, 2007 11:11 am:
" Amanda is not employed in Gage County whatsoever. Again, get your facts straight. "

Get it Straight wrote on November 16, 2007 11:32 am:
" Dear Anyone Notice: Obviously you have not read and got your facts straight. Officer May is not employed at Gage County. Read a little closer - names are almost the same but a big difference. "

respondanyonenotice wrote on November 16, 2007 1:16 pm:
" It is not Amanda May at Gage County Detention Center/Deputy. It is Amanda Bay. Get your facts straight. "

tom issquah wrote on November 16, 2007 2:06 pm:
" A tragic "accident". Two victims this dear girl and the police officer. Why the lawsuit? Because this is the world we live in. The only winner here is the attorney as he will collect his 33%. God Bless you Jena and will pray for a full recovery for you and your family. "

Just wondering wrote on November 16, 2007 2:20 pm:
" I have a question for all the cops that keep sending comments. Why was the officer asked to resign (fired)? After all "she was just doing her job"? Sounds strange doesn't it? "

Father of two girls wrote on November 16, 2007 3:38 pm:
" I for one will take this accident for real. The blame game is awful, but as a parent of teen girls, I am attempting to show them how important it is to make good decisions. We would all be better served if we would all be responsible for our own actions. I agree with LTR on at least one point. The article indirectly implicates the officer, when the most uncomfortable facts are that the teens were crossing where they should not have been and proper caution to the wind. I'll now say a prayer for both families. "

Amanda wrote on November 16, 2007 4:00 pm:
" I guess I didn't realize how bad off she was. I graduated with her. It's sad they all have to suffer like this. I just hope for the best outcome. "

Chelsea Hahn wrote on November 16, 2007 8:30 pm:
" Keep fighting kiddo, you're gonna make it through this!! "

crs wrote on November 17, 2007 5:23 pm:
" What a sad story and my prayers go out to her and her family. I went to school with her and she seemed like a very nice and caring girl. To all of you who think its wrong that the are sueing then think of it this way... what if it was your child? why didn't the officer have his/her lights on driving that fast? or his/her siren? I mean it doesn't matter what she was doing at that hour or anything its the fact that she is seriuosly injured and it shouldn't of happened. "

Friend since High School (* Strutters *) wrote on November 18, 2007 10:28 pm:
" I'm so sorry to Jena's friends and family for all the rude and hurtful comments. I can't believe how inconsiderate people can be. What is this world coming to? Think about it, those of you that left those hateful comments, this young woman is fighting for her life and is one of the strongest people I have ever known. She is not the irresponsible punk teenager like you make her out to be. She is a very mature and beautiful person. Not only was she a mentor in High School, but she is also an incredible person. She always knows how to make someone laugh and give others a helping hand. This is our time to help her and pray for her. Like others have said, what if this was you or your child? Could you imagine reading some of these comments and not getting furious? It hurts me to know this is what society has come to. A young woman is facing the biggest fight in her life and you people are inconsiderate and too concerned about your taxes and yourself. You people make me sick! To those who care and help us family and friends pray for her...God Bless you! As for Jena, keep fighting girl! Love you! "

Cole Franson wrote on November 26, 2007 12:49 am:
" Hey Jena, Having a couple classes with ya at LNE was fun mainly because the classes we had were horrible and you at least gave me someone to talk to. I want you to know that I am so sorry about what happened to you, and if I can ever help out in any way at all, please just ask. I want all of you people who are writing this junk about how she was out too late, or how she walked illegaly, or how she stepped out in front of the car to seriously look at what you are saying. Quit blaming this entire thing on somebody or some action that happened or should have happened. You people have no heart if you really come on here and write about the poor cop. I mean really? A girls life was almost over and you are crying about a cop that lost her job? I'm sorry she lost her job, and maybe that was a little too far, but I do not think any of you need to be getting on here and crying about it. As someone said what if it was your kid, or even you? What if your child gets in a horrible accident and you see people write this kind of thing about her? I mean this really is rediculous. I wish you could forget about money, or a job, or whatever else is on here and remember a girl who I didn't even know very well but always had a smile on her face and would always try to cheer you up when you were down. Maybe we should encourage one another, it might make a huge difference in someones life. Jena we are all praying for you!! "

John wrote on December 19, 2007 7:41 pm:
" The reason Jena's family is suing is because every year, hundreds of people are injured due to Police officers going to emergency calls too fast or without lights and sirens (which applies to his situation). Those numbers are obviously too high. Perhaps something needs to be changed regarding that. Another thing, being out at 1230 isn't a crime. I would venture to guess that many of you have been out at 1230 and not been doing anything wrong. And if you were doing something wrong, maybe you should hold judgments. She was 18; everyone that age is out past midnight so to put her at fault simply because she was still awake is ridiculous. How often do your 18 year olds stay out past 12? "