Now
Fair
71.0°
High
87°
Low
64°

Staff has vision for Bennett Martin library

Text Size: 
Tools Sponsor

BY KENDRA WALTKE / Lincoln Journal Star

Tuesday, Aug 14, 2007 - 11:36:50 am CDT

A larger, more exciting downtown library could attract people from all over the city.

It could serve as a centerpiece for downtown, or at least become one of its anchor amenities.

The current Bennett Martin Public Library could be much  more, according to the vision of the Lincoln City Libraries staff and trustees. But don’t look for construction to start any time soon.

Story Photo
Kayla Anderson browses in the stacks of Bennett Martin Library. (William Lauer)

At this point, it’s a matter of finding money and the right location, and getting the right people on board, said Jeff Kirkpatrick, a Lincoln City Libraries trustee.

The right location is a major challenge because the library board envisions a full city block for a new main library.

That may have prompted the rumor that Bennett Martin could move into a renovated Pershing Center if a new arena is built and the downtown auditorium is vacated.

It’s true that moving Pershing would provide a great opportunity for building a new library, said Carol Connor, director of Lincoln City Libraries. Using the Pershing building itself, however, has been ruled out. 

“It would be a challenge to make it functional,” Connor said.

If the space became available, she said, the library board would be very interested in building a new main library there. However, lots of other entities might have their eye on the space as well. “I’m sure we wouldn’t be the only ones interested,” she said.

In any case, the library board would prefer to build a new building on a downtown lot large enough to provide parking.

The idea of updating the main library has been tossed about for several years, even before a 2003 study by Clark Enersen architects and a library consultant identified a concept.

A public library has stood at 14th and N streets for more than a century, starting with a Carnegie library built in 1902. The current library was built in three phases, starting in 1960 with a gift from businessman and former mayor Bennett Martin and his wife, Dorothy.

It has been maintained well, and  in recent years, private money paid for updates to the children’s area, Connor said. Other improvements also have been made.

But Bennett Martin Public Library as it stands is an undersized building with antiquated utilities and little flexibility for adding services, Connor said.

The 2003 study looked at expanding and renovating the library, but “The architects said no, you just don’t have the foundation there,” Kirkpatrick said.

The Pershing renovation prospect was explored in light of Peru State College’s recent conversion of an old gym into a new library. But Pershing proved to be a bad option because of how the building is laid out, Kirkpatrick said, “You would have a lot of space that is not usable but that you still need to heat and cool.”

The 2003 study proposed building a new 150,000-square-foot library, more than twice the 64,000 square feet Bennett Martin now occupies.

The cost is estimated at $47.5 million for construction starting in 2012, Connor said. The 2003 estimate had been around $30 million.

A new downtown library would not need to stand alone, Connor said. It could be a true downtown destination paired with other uses, such as street-level retail, Connor said.

“It might sound a little unusual, but libraries can contribute to the economic development in a downtown center,” she said, “You have to make it exciting and attractive.”

She pointed to libraries such as one in Des Moines, Iowa, that has  become part of the city’s cultural scene.

Also, a new library could be designed in a way that would keep operational costs down, Connor said, because it could use energy more efficiently and be more functional for library staff.

Without a location or funding in place, building a new downtown library is, for now, a distant plan.

It is not one of the 10 pillars identified by the 2015 Vision Group, a group of civic and business leaders that has identified priorities and begun raising private money to help finance Lincoln’s future.

That private group’s downtown development committee is mostly looking at things such as retail and transportation improvements.

But Kirkpatrick, who, in addition to sitting on the library board, is involved with both the 2015 Vision Group and its downtown subcommittee, thinks a new library would be a good fit with that group’s ideas.

“I hope the energy that is being generated by 2015 would help us,” he said. “It could drum up the public support we’d need.”

Though, he added, “I wouldn’t feel comfortable saying (a new library) is key until the city says they’re ready to move forward.”

A new downtown library is included in the city’s long-range Capital Improvement Plan but that does not mean it has any priority.

“When you’ve gone through the (city) budget cycle that we’ve gone through, to build a new library, that’s a hard thing to say,” Kirkpatrick said.

“It would be easier to dream if the sales tax revenues were up.”

A major donation also could get things rolling, he said.

“It’s really a question of timing because it’s not a decision the library board can make; it’s a city and community decision.”

Reach Kendra Waltke at (402) 473-7303 or kwaltke@journalstar.com.


$1 Sunday Delivery - Subscribe Today!
Local > Back to Top of Story

All posts to JournalStar.com are subject to our Terms and Standards.
Your posted comment will appear after it has been approved.
Frequently asked questions about story commenting.
(optional)
   
rac wrote on August 14, 2007 8:12 am:
" Don't see any point in using my tax dollars for this - the library downtown is used mostly as a shelter for homeless and bums anyways. The internet has virtually eliminated the need for libraries, im my opionion. Let's keep with the 2015 groups plans and not add the extra fluff, not necessary. "

geraldine mcgufferson wrote on August 14, 2007 8:27 am:
" I don't take my kids to the downtown library because it seems to have become a daytime shelter for all the local hobos. "

Grant Landreth wrote on August 14, 2007 9:05 am:
" Removing Pershing would be very detrimental to the look and feel of capital mall. It also is one of several mid-century buildings that tell the story of Lincoln's push during the 50s and 60s to construct buildings of permanance and quality. I highly doubt that there will be money in the budget to construct a building with materials and craftmanship of similar qualities. Pershing and the Alltel (Windstream) building are "bookends" on either side of the mall...using similar stone and massing. Without one...the other loses much of its architectural significance. Aside from all of that. So, the public (city) will be asked to provide monies for the new arena which will replace Pershing. With Pershing gone, taxpayers will again be asked to provide monies for a new library. Seems like this could be a downward spiral with no end in sight. Next thing you know, the city will decrease funding for firefighters, police, parks, programs for the aging. Oh wait, the city is already doing this. Where is the money coming from? I am 28 years old. I own a house in Country Club area. I enjoy old buildings. With the new arena proposed as an attachment to Lincoln Station and now Pershing proposed as to be torn down... I don't think that I can leave fast enough. My partner and I are professional with expendible income. It seems that 2015 is trying to keep people like us in Lincoln. Instead, there "vision" is making it easier to leave. So we will leave with our expendible income and are college degrees to go live in a bigger city that appreciates "real" urbanity and historic preservation. Good luck Lincoln! "

Timmy wrote on August 14, 2007 9:06 am:
" The attitude of the first two posters here provides an answer to a rhetorical question I've been asking my students for about a decade now. Given the current cultural climate of the United States, if they did not yet exist and somebody came up with the idea for public libraries today would the idea be supported and funded? Most of my students reason that, no, in today's climate where the attitude seems to be 'I've got mine, and if you don't it's your own fault and don't come looking to me,' with no thought for the greater public good and a sense of noblesse oblige that could once be found in the United States, public libraries would not exist if they were not a tradition carried forward from a time of greater civic mindedness in our nation's past. This, of course, begs that larger question of just what has become of the United States? "

t wrote on August 14, 2007 9:18 am:
" "the internet has virtually eliminated the need for libraries"; "extra fluff" ??!! i hope you don't have children. libraries are very valuable especially well-designed ones that attract all ages with their layout, resources, and events. this idea would be a great improvement to the downtown library.....but unfortunately it looks like it'll have to wait a while. "

NS wrote on August 14, 2007 9:25 am:
" A good place to start for donations would be the Bill and Melinda Gates foundation. They are highly dedicated to providing funding for public libraries. They built a brand new several million dollar facility for the city of Seattle a few years ago and have donated money to many other public libraries over the years. It would definitely be worth a shot. Never hurts to ask, and maybe if they can get a good start on donation money others would be encouraged to donate as well. "

uhuh... wrote on August 14, 2007 10:05 am:
" As for the down trodden and poor (bums+hobos) in our city using public facilities, why shouldn't they be allowed to take a respite from the hasrh elements in which they live? Shame on you- Where is your compassion for the poor? "

Future Librarian wrote on August 14, 2007 10:15 am:
" Even though the general public often does not realize it, libraries are essential and should be given consideration for improvement, whether from tax dollars or private donation. "

library lover wrote on August 14, 2007 10:28 am:
" I use the libraries with great frequency, particularly Bennett Martin. I mentor with LPS and my students like to read a variety of books that are not held by the LPS libraries. I'm not rich either, so when we want to read something different I go to the libraries and check it out. Expanding Bennett Martin would allow them carry an even larger canon of literature. This would be very nice as it would open up new discussions. I think public libraries are among our greatest treasures as a society. If we have a problem with homeless people frequenting our libraries then there are larder questions that should be addressed. Why do we have such a large homeless population when we are supposedly the wealthies nation in the world? and, Where is our humanity if we would seek to take away one of the last refuges of a downtrodden member of our society? The test of a society is not how it treats its best members, but how it treats its worst. "

Bob wrote on August 14, 2007 10:45 am:
" I would concur that the internet has drastically altered the need for libraries. The key question is "how many people use the library." Also, is this the best use of $50 million for the city. I would venture that it isn't. It would also require doubling staff (no doubt) and doubling utility cost, etc. Recognize also, that the internet will continue to expand its capabilities in the future. The capability to provide internet services has hardly begun. Twenty years from now, we will laugh at how "archaic" the early internet was. So, what is the cost/benefit to the city in the future of a $50 million (plus large recurring costs) library? . "

I'll offer some of my tax dollars wrote on August 14, 2007 11:23 am:
" When I moved from Lincoln to California, I was appalled at the quality of the libraries in comparison to what we have here. The first thing I did when I got back was obtain a library card and start going back to Bennett Martin. I'm grateful for our public library system and would be very happy to help in any way I can to insure that this system is able to continue to exist and expand. "

SM wrote on August 14, 2007 11:33 am:
" Why not try to improve parking with the money. "

just an idea wrote on August 14, 2007 11:57 am:
" With the presumed going away of Pershing, why doesn't the city sell that bldg/land to a PRIVATE enterprise and take that money and expand Bennet Martin. Since the Pershing site is expected to be such a valuable piece of property, I am sure the money obtained would be more than enough to expand our current downtown library. I for one however like the idea of making Pershing a 'Central' library where books can come in, be inventoried, stored, repaired and the grass on the south side can be converted to parking for probably 100 cars. Too logical for this city though?? "

rac wrote on August 14, 2007 12:08 pm:
" So you've managed to define the difference between liberals and conservatives for your students; good for you. Liberals will always ask "where is your sense of compassion?", while conservatives will always retort with "where's your sense of responsibility?". It's been going on for ages, and I don't think it's changed much recently, other than both sides have become more vocal. One thing that has changed is the need for libraries. I liken the concept of libraries much to that of labor unions: they once had a public social purpose, but times have changed. It would be nice if we could get off of the concept that we need to continue an institution just because "it's always been there". The need for publically (tax) funded libraries is just not there anymore in a city the size of Lincoln with ample internet access. And I would rather make a donation to the City Mission then fund libraries with taxes year after year... "

Carmelo wrote on August 14, 2007 12:47 pm:
" So don't Bill & Melinda Gates think that "the internet has virtually eliminated the need for libraries"? I guess I'm confused. Do you lay in bed at night reading novels on your computer? The library is essential. If you don't agree, then perhaps you need to do some heavy thinking. "

frankly wrote on August 14, 2007 1:01 pm:
" Who is this Conner, she seems as out dated as most of the people in the 10 pillars group. I think lincoln needs new diretors and people to think the city forward. Isn't the city in a budget crises Conner? More of the same, you sit in a chair for 30 years putting together budgets that got the city in this fiscal mess. "

Usage report wrote on August 14, 2007 1:35 pm:
" I would be willing to bet that more people use the bike trail in a single day between South Street and Van Dorn in the linear Antelope Park than combined library use in one month. Bennett Martin Library is a homeless shelter with books and dirty carpet. I use it when I can, but many times the disturbances and odors simply cause me to leave. The staff and "security" there do nothing to correct behavior inside the library. My tax dollars support that library, however, the way it is managed I would prefer if it closed, or had its budget and hours reduced so that trails, parks and other high use assets of the city received proper funding. I think libraries are great, but when Bennett Martin is used as a shelter, I have to wonder about funding it because there are other facilities in town that are built for and staffed to serve as day shelters. "

Knowledge wrote on August 14, 2007 2:07 pm:
" Why would the rich want you to receive an education and empower yourself on their dime? They would rather see you be ignorant and subservient. But I bet if you asked, they have probably used a library in there lives. "

Crack the Closed Minds wrote on August 14, 2007 2:09 pm:
" First of all, we're doomed if the Internet is a replacement for libraries. Second,try getting out a little and you'll see the benefits of investing in community. Chicago has a great, recently-built library right downtown. It's a beautiful building swarming with people visiting the library and attending exhibits and other cool happenings. And I don't remember seeing any bums or hobos. "

Tom wrote on August 14, 2007 2:14 pm:
" Lincoln's downtown library is a good library but it is downtown, which is a pretty much a zoo for the millions of homeless people that roam Lincoln. The city should make it into a Library/Homeless Shelter, that would combine the library with the true feel of downtown Lincoln. Perhaps they could put a bar in there as well. "

John B wrote on August 14, 2007 2:41 pm:
" Sounds like some of these people have never been downtown. It only shows the need to have more things to get them to come downtown. The reason like has some homeless people is because the know Lincoln is safe place to be. The internet is not going to replace books. At one time people thought the computer was going remove the need for paper, but we all know it did just the opposit. Pershing is on it's last leg and would be a great location. That is where Lincoln High was orginally located. "

Big Chief wrote on August 14, 2007 2:46 pm:
" I visit branches of the Lincoln libraries quite often. Yes Bennet/Martin does seem to attract a lot of homeless people but there is a security guard on duty. Maybe these homeless people are going through the classifieds searching for job opportunities. I am sure that $.50 to buy a newspaper is not a priority in a homeless persons budget so the library newspapers are a great resource for them. Does Bennet/Martin have a history of problems with this homeless crowd? If so I sure haven't seen or heard of them. Our libraries are a valuable asset to all types of citizens. "

G wrote on August 14, 2007 3:17 pm:
" I think the "central" library needs to be moved out of downtown. Downtown is no longer the center of town. 27th & O might be good, but it's too crowded (not enough space). How about putting it at 48th & O (forget Hy-Vee). That is close or soon will be close to the center of Lincoln. [I'm saying this as a resident of west Lincoln, so while downtown is "closer" for me. I feel 48th and O makes the most sense as a central/main library.] "

down on know-it-alls wrote on August 14, 2007 3:49 pm:
" Some comments below about the homeless are pretty self-righteous, if not to say outright heartless. In a democracy we accommodate everyone and treat them in an equally warm and welcoming manner. Bet some of the "hobos," as you call them, have more active minds than the people below who limn them in such predictable terms. I'd much rather eat lunch with some of them than with some of you. If you think the people in Lincoln we think deserve to sleep in cardboard boxes on the pavement congregate in Lincoln's libraries, try visiting Santa Monica, Berkeley or San Francisco. Being in the library only says someone wants to improve. That's a smart choice of activities, no? "

KB wrote on August 14, 2007 4:24 pm:
" Several have said, including Michael Eisher (Disney) just today said, more and more people read papers and can find more things on the internet than ever before. I know I haven't taken a paper in years. I use to go to libraries years ago, not now I look up what ever I want on the internet. I like all these comments that know exactly why we need all these buildings and who to rake the money out of and they probably don't even own their own homes let alone their cars!!! "

I love the libraries wrote on August 14, 2007 5:10 pm:
" I'd be more than happy to donate to a new central library. My kids (grown) loved the trips to Gere and Walt. The Internet is great, but it will never replace the library...only enhance it. "

Scott wrote on August 14, 2007 8:53 pm:
" I'm afraid that the same people who find the library useless are people who think that Wikipedia is a useful source for research. The internet will never replace print. "

Hmmm... wrote on August 14, 2007 9:03 pm:
" So, maybe these homeless people actually enjoy reading also, ever think about that!!! "

Anna wrote on August 14, 2007 9:09 pm:
" I love the internet!! I've been online since 1995. That being said, I also go to the library anywhere from 1 to 4 times a month. My kids love picking out books just as much as they love playing on the computer. I'm all for the improvement of our cities libraries. "

Angie wrote on August 14, 2007 9:21 pm:
" I personally don't have an opinion on this downtown library, because I hardly ever go downtown. But I do not think the internet will completely replace a library. I don't at this time in my life have a lot of time to read books, but who wants to read a book off the internet?! And what about those out there who may not have a computer (yes, I am sure there are some). What are they supposed to do? Not everyone can afford what the rest of us have obviously taken for granted. A lot of times, I purchase books for my children, but sometimes we like to go to the library. "

E wrote on August 14, 2007 9:54 pm:
" If we tear down Pershing and build a new library in it's place, where will we have Rib Fest? I doubt a library would want people with BBQ sauce sticky fingers fumbling through their books!!! "

Bethany Library wrote on August 14, 2007 9:58 pm:
" I suggest that they do something with the Bethany library instead of Bennett Martian. I just recently went to the Bethany library and I was sadden to see that they have nothing compared to any of the other librarys. Those famlies in that area deserve to have a better library than what they have. "

Scott wrote on August 14, 2007 10:06 pm:
" Lincoln should jump at any opportunity to improve their downtown library. I live in a county in southern Oregon that doesn't HAVE libraries any more. While there's a lot of things available on the internet now-a-days, it's hard to find a copy of "Where the Wild Things Are" or "On the Road" or any of the other classics. As for a downtown location, having civic buildings downtown shows Lincoln's support for the area. It promotes investment and redevelopment. Scratch the parking, though, and use the money for a public transportation system that actually works that can get people downtown. "

Kristine wrote on August 15, 2007 8:59 am:
" There is NOTHING like sitting in a chair on a cold, dreary day and reading a good book. If books are SO outdated, then why do major television talk show hosts give their whole audiences books and those who receive them are thrilled?? How many people stood in line all over the WORLD and waited for the latest Harry Potter?? Although the internet is a fount of information, it will NEVER replace books. I need books for research papers at UNL. If books are so outdated, why are all the new ones checked out all the time?? It is not a point of, they have always been there, either. Obviously, the negative posters on here have never enjoyed reading. I LOVE to read and I will always support the public library system. It makes me sick that some people are so opposed to libraries here. I can't afford to buy books, so the library suits my needs. Every time I go, they are always busy. If books were so outdated, why is Barnes and Noble always teeming with people?? People love books and the library makes that possible for people who can't afford to buy them. Not everyone in the world uses the internet, either! Have you ever thought of that, naysayers?? "

Lisa wrote on August 15, 2007 10:55 am:
" Homeless people would quit asking for money and seeking shelter if people weren't stupid enough to give them money. Do any of you have any idea on how much tax free $$ they make? Not my problem none of them have the desire to ask stores (or even the library) for a job application. I love the idea of a remodeled/new library. Books will never be replaced. I love going to the library. Even my trip to Chicago last weekend I took a book on tape to help combat fatigue. Bums are the least of my worries - bring on more books!!! "

Except the homeless in Lincoln? wrote on August 15, 2007 2:08 pm:
" There is not such a cradle of democracy upon the earth as the Free Public Library, this republic of letters, where neither rank, office, nor wealth receives the slightest consideration. ~Andrew Carnegie "

Library Patron wrote on August 16, 2007 11:03 am:
" "If this nation is to be wise as well as strong, if we are to achieve our destiny, then we need more new ideas for more wise men reading more good books in more public libraries. These libraries should be open to allexcept the censor. We must know all the facts and hear all the alternatives and listen to all the criticisms. Let us welcome controversial books and controversial authors. For the Bill of Rights is the guardian of our security as well as our liberty. " Kennedy, John F. "