Now
Overcast
34°
High
36°
Low
13°

Svoboda's contract for median landscaping extended

Text Size: 
Tools Sponsor

By DEENA WINTER / Lincoln Journal Star

Wednesday, Mar 28, 2007 - 11:16:06 am CDT

Blame it on the poppy mallow.

The purple-and-white perennial has been so difficult to grow on east Lincoln medians the mayor extended a landscaping contract, delaying damages to give the contractor time to try — again — to grow the plants.

This wouldn’t be news, except the contract belongs to Councilman Ken Svoboda’s family-owned landscaping company.

City council, city contracts

Councilman Ken Svoboda’s family-owned landscaping company has earned an average of $30,000 per year doing work for the city during the past decade, according to city records.

While some have questioned whether Svoboda’s contracts are a conflict of interest, City Attorney Dana Roper said nothing in city ordinances prohibits council members from doing business with the city, although they must disclose the business relationship to the Nebraska Accountability and Disclosure Commission.

Also, Svoboda should excuse himself from voting on his own contracts, Roper said. Ray’s Lawn and Home Care won the contracts because it was the low bidder.

According to City Finance Director Don Herz, the city has paid Ray’s nearly $300,000 for work done since 1997. The company didn’t start receiving significant payments until 2000, one year before Svoboda was elected to the City Council.

Svoboda has previously said he does not intend to extend his contracts once they expire, because it would be a conflict of interest if he were elected mayor.

The Democratic candidate for mayor, Chris Beutler, also had an annual contract to raise funds for the Parks and Recreation Department from 2000, when he was hired by former Mayor Don Wesely, until he terminated the contract in January. He was paid $62,000 to work an average of 1,250 hours annually, or about 24 hours per week, according to his last contract.

Svoboda is running for mayor in Tuesday’s primary election.

Nearly a year ago, public works director Karl Fredrickson took the unusual step of threatening to terminate Svoboda’s company’s median landscape maintenance contracts because he said the medians were overrun with weeds.

He gave Svoboda time to get the medians in order, and the contracts were salvaged.

But Svoboda’s median troubles didn’t end there.

This time, the mayor signed a change order because Fredrickson said Ray’s Lawn and Home Care didn’t perform on a contract to install landscaping on several blocks of 84th Street between South Street and Montello Court.

The work was supposed to have been done two years ago and still isn’t complete, Fredrickson said.

Change orders aren’t that unusual on city contracts, especially on big construction projects. But this change order is different in that it doesn’t change a part specification or change the type of trees to be planted, for example.

Svoboda said the only reason he hasn’t completed the contract is the poppy mallow the city specified has been difficult to get established, even though it’s supposed to thrive in hot, sunny locations.

Everything else — from trees to buffalo grass — are fine, he said.

“We have replanted multiple times to try to get them established,” he said, noting the perennials have struggled on other city medians in east Lincoln.

Both sides agreed to extend the contract until everyone is satisfied, he said. He didn’t think a change order was necessary, but said it was done so everything would be transparent.

“I’m not (satisfied) and obviously the city is not,” he said.

Poppy mallows will be replanted again within the next two weeks, he said.

“We’ve done everything we’ve been asked to do at great cost to our company,” Svoboda said.

But Fredrickson said some of the plants have died and some haven’t been planted, so Svoboda never reached the number of plants required by the contract.

And while any landscaper would have had trouble establishing plants during recent drought years, Fredrickson said, the poppy mallow is a prairie plant.

“We didn’t have a contract with the poppy mallows,” he said.

In an effort to resolve the matter, earlier this month the mayor and Svoboda signed the change order, extending the completion date and altering the terms of the contract.

The change order says:



  • The city will deduct damages due to costs associated with an outside consultant’s time and for past and projected staff time dealing with the contract. The city said it had accrued $12,483 in damages as of March 7.



  • Daily liquidated damages will be increased from $100 a day to $200 a day if Svoboda doesn’t get the work finished by May 1.



  • Ray’s must provide the city with a $75,000 letter of credit, on which the city can draw if Ray’s defaults on the contract. The credit line would replace the performance bond, which contractors provide as a form of insurance that they will complete jobs. Performance bonds can be difficult to collect, however.



  • The completion date was extended to May 1 (coincidentally, the date when the next mayor will be elected).



  • In exchange for all of the above, the city agreed not to pursue collection of liquidated damages that had accrued as of March 7.





The city has hired contractors to maintain medians for about six years, since it started sprucing them up with flowers, shrubs and grasses.

The drought has been hard on the medians, most of which aren't irrigated, and sometimes the weeds get ahead of contractors. The city doesn’t have as many median contracts due to budget constraints.

The situation puts Fredrickson in an awkward position because, if Svoboda is elected mayor, he would be his boss. And the mayor can terminate directors such as Fredrickson for any reason.

Mayor Coleen Seng appointed Fredrickson two years ago.

“It’s a position I don’t desire to be in but it’s part of the job to administer contracts and I do my job,” he said. “If Ken gets to be mayor, I’ll do my job with any contract the same way. He’s not gonna be treated any differently because he’s on council or mayor.”

In his mayoral campaign, Svoboda has touted his experience running a business.

But Eric Fought, communications director for the Nebraska Democratic Party, said the change order “says a lot about Ken Svoboda’s ability to effectively run a business.”

“Where I come from, you get the job done in the time allotted, or you don’t get paid,” said Fought, who provided a copy of the change order to the Journal Star.

“The city has given Ken Svoboda more second chances than a cat has lives. Lincoln needs a leader who will get the job done, not someone who keeps passing the buck.”

Svoboda said the Democrats are politicizing the situation.

But Fredrickson said politics has nothing to do with the matter.

“You got a contract and you got two parties. All I am doing is trying to administer the contract to final completion for the benefit of the taxpayer. I may be appointed, but I’m not here for the politics.”

Reach Deena Winter at 473-2642 or dwinter@journalstar.com.


$1 Sunday Delivery - Subscribe Today!
Local > Back to Top of Story

All posts to JournalStar.com are subject to our Terms and Standards.
Your posted comment will appear after it has been approved.
Frequently asked questions about story commenting.
(optional)
   
nlloftis wrote on March 28, 2007 7:23 am:
" I would prefer the discussion be why we are frittering with flowers in an inappropriate environment in the first place. "

Bill in Lincoln wrote on March 28, 2007 8:18 am:
" ....kudos to Karl Fredrickson for staying on top of the situation. I didn't realize this.... It's turning in to a "he says...they say....I say....," situation. Plants dying and not being planted and not up to the number agreed upon are enough information for me to formulate an opinion when it comes to ballot time! "

Sean1 wrote on March 28, 2007 8:23 am:
" Politics or not. This is the taxpayers dime Mr. Svoboda. FIX IT! "

story smells wrote on March 28, 2007 8:33 am:
" Boy this story smells, and not of poppy mallow, but of ugly politics. This announcement was clearly a calculated move by Beulters campaign manager, who worked in the Mayors office and was privy to such documents...So the real question is...how much time did rick hoppee spend doing campaign work while on mayor sengs staff and our tax dollar? "

Accountability! wrote on March 28, 2007 8:34 am:
" This story says it all about who will bring accountability and integrity to the Mayor's Office, and who won't. "

You've got to be kidding me! wrote on March 28, 2007 8:41 am:
" The city made him put up personal money as a guarantee against the work? Geez, if any other contractor was this unreliable and sketchy, I can't imagine the city would be bending over backwards to keep them on. "

Marc wrote on March 28, 2007 8:54 am:
" It seems to me that we are in the midst of a budget shortfall for the city. Why are we spending additional monies on medians, when they should be concreted or bricked once and for all!!!! "

nitemare wrote on March 28, 2007 9:00 am:
" Just goes to show, again, that in Lincoln the most important thing is who you are and who you know! If you are not "one of the family", you will never have a chance in this little metropolis!! Let's get the "names" out of office, and start out with some new blodd!! "

Mike wrote on March 28, 2007 9:24 am:
" I find the timing of the story interesting to say the least. Since the primary election is next week, this appears to be politically motivated. For what it is worth, I have seen Ken Svoboda working on the medians at 84th and Montello road, as I work near there. "

concerned wrote on March 28, 2007 9:24 am:
" This is clearly a indication how Ken Svoboda would run the Mayor's office if elected. "

wasted money wrote on March 28, 2007 9:28 am:
" When your budget consists mainly of capital improvement projects it really makes the shortfall seem trivial and political. Yet every year we are threatened with lay offs’ in our public safety area first. Story smells, these things are public record and can be found within the city’s web site, just like how a contract was awarded for cameras inside the public bus system for over $60,000. Something I’m sure we absolutely needed in these lean times… "

Dawg wrote on March 28, 2007 9:41 am:
" The city sure tuff on flowers. To bad they aren't tuff when the shoe is on the other foot. The city plowed my rental property alley way. The grader hit the garage, I talk to city roads department and the driver of the grader admitted he hit the garage but they said oh to bad. "

just curious wrote on March 28, 2007 9:45 am:
" Just curious as to why the city would go after Svoboda with such venegance but have forgiven all the fire truck late fees and pemalties. Guess nobody at the fire truck place was running for Mayor. "

frankly wrote on March 28, 2007 9:50 am:
" in lean times the most important things to seng are mediums? there are still pot holes all over the city, FIX THEM. get the city managers to work an stop the politics. this mayor race is going to turn into a joke just like the city directors,management and every person on the city council. "

Mike wrote on March 28, 2007 9:51 am:
" Yes it does speak to who would bring integrity to the mayors office...and its Svoboda, a small business man who responded to the city and is working with them...verses Beutler the career politician who excels in throwing mud, but has done nothing in his nearly quarter century of politics to support business and economic growth. Its also telling how the press never mentions Beutlers failed business. "

humm wrote on March 28, 2007 10:12 am:
" The question to be asked is the City treating him any different than other contractors? If yes then there is a problem, if no then this is a moot point. "

the answer man wrote on March 28, 2007 10:40 am:
" What this story says is Ken Svoboda has accomplished all of his contract with the city EXCEPT the poppy mallow trees. And because nature has not allowed them to take root and grow, Svoboda is responsible, according to the newspaper. "

Mike Honcho wrote on March 28, 2007 10:56 am:
" Gosh, d'ya think the current drought and the medians saturated with road salt might make it a problem to grow something there? I'm surprised anything grows in the medians...and I think the fact that Ken's company is able to get anything to grow there is a testament to the kind of work he does. I'm not really sure why we continue to grow things in the medians...they obstruct the view of the opposite lanes, making it difficult to see possible oncoming danger. "

Really wrote on March 28, 2007 11:25 am:
" What does this story have to do with Beutler? I think it’s fair to say that the city reporter who wrote this article is far from friendly to the Democrats. So I find it funny that some here think it’s a conspiracy against Svoboda. If you read the article for what it is I would say that it’s more of a follow up to an issue of not fulfilling a contract held by the city and Rays that was brought up before the Mayors race ever became an issue. So if that’s the kind of guy you support, that’s scary. Because if he’s not willing/able to fulfill a yard work contract what other contracts is he willing not to fulfill? "

concerned wrote on March 28, 2007 12:11 pm:
" This is a perfect example of how this city runs on the "Good old boy network". Svoboda wants to run the city, but can't even handle the medians??? "

It Ain't Rocket Science wrote on March 28, 2007 12:17 pm:
" If Ken is incapable of doing simple median maintenance work - how on earth is he going to manage a complicated city budget? "

No More Excuses wrote on March 28, 2007 12:20 pm:
" From what I have seen no mud has been thrown by Chris Beutler. It was Ken Svoboda on attack making excuses yet again, on why he is unable to complete another task. Whether maintaining the medians - which he choose to bid on - or not being able to get anything done on council because of the "democrats"- there seems to always be an excuse. . . "

Let’s not be naïve wrote on March 28, 2007 1:08 pm:
" This story has much to do about Beutler and the democrats who control city hall. This clearly was a political attack on a small business. The posting that said he is not willing or able to fulfill the contract is simply untrue and more political posturing. So let’s be real, we’re talking about replacing some flowers that died -which would be a non-story except for the owner of the small business is a republican running for mayor. Heaven forbid! The fact that Beutler’s campaign manager worked in the city hall and had access to these documents, combined with the fact the democratic party is pushing this non-story sure brings Beutler and his campaign manager into the issue. To me, this speaks more on the negative political agenda of the democrats and beutler campaign vs a business owner who indeed is making good on the terms of a contract. "

jmk wrote on March 28, 2007 1:22 pm:
" seems to me as though this is a conflict of interest. Why is a councilman or any city official being given a contract to service the town? Yet another reason to vote for Beulter. "

Jim wrote on March 28, 2007 2:15 pm:
" FYI the money spent on cameras for the buses was from federal tax dollars not city dollars. You would be surprised how much money has been saved for the city on faulty claims against the city for slips and falls, accidents etc. Money well spent. "

smells like spring wrote on March 28, 2007 2:29 pm:
" Ahh the flowers are blooming but the sweet smell of the season is being invaded by the nasty scent of politics. To question the contract is certainly legit, but to say he is not fulfilling it is just political rhetoric. Rays is making good on the terms of the contract, and that is no story, let alone front page. But enter the democrat spin machine and we have instant fertilizer. So let's clear the air, because the choice is clear...Ken Svoboda-an energetic, business leader with the drive and vision to bring economic growth to lincoln, vs. a failed businessman and tired career politician who would still be milling about quietly in the legislative garden if not for term limits. Let's make this subject take root and bloom. "

SCOTT HANSEN wrote on March 28, 2007 3:03 pm:
" WRITE ME IN FOR MAYOR!!! This is a conflict of interest for the city and one more reason that our little country town is in need of BIG change in local government! Don't trust Bite-ler...don't trust a Svoboda....and Yant?....well, he speaks for himself. Lincoln is in desperate need of a major government overhaul!!! "

Small business owner, yes. Smart businessman, no. wrote on March 28, 2007 3:11 pm:
" This story is not an attack on all small business people. This story is a criticism of one business owner who is not living up to a contract. In fact, Ray's lawn service did not live up to a verbal contract for lawn service at my house either. The City should do what I did, and never hire him for landscape maintenance again! "

Fred will fit in just fine wrote on March 28, 2007 3:48 pm:
" Mr. Frederickson seems to be hedging his bets that beutler will become mayor. If so, he'll fit in just fine in a beutler administration, who like Seng, and Wesely, is no friend to small businesses. "

wake up! wrote on March 28, 2007 4:23 pm:
" Maybe the City choosing the "lowest bidder" for the landscaping contract isn't always the best way to go. Goes to show you that we didn't save any money in the long run. Get with it! There are other professional Lawn care companies out there with great service after the sale! Shame on us twice for extending the contract. "

Conflict of interest? wrote on March 28, 2007 4:26 pm:
" "While some have questioned whether Svoboda’s contracts are a conflict of interest, City Attorney Dana Roper said nothing in city ordinances prohibits council members from doing business with the city, although they must disclose the business relationship to the Nebraska Accountability and Disclosure Commission" How can the people of lincoln let this go on. This is why the taxes are so freaking high in this city. These people sitting on the council are only there for personal gain. This must be stopped. "

whos naïve? wrote on March 28, 2007 5:10 pm:
" I’m sorry but the point of this story and the previous story this earlier this year was that a COUNCIL person was NOT fulfilling his contract, hence the story. Why is this interesting? It’s interesting due to the appearance that a person who could have immeasurable influence over said contracts is having problems fulfilling his obligations. Also from a Mayoral standpoint I find it interesting because if you look at the candidates’ web site he says he wants to; “return fiscal discipline to City Hall”. So the question beckons, do you intend to return fiscal discipline by not fulfilling contracts? I think it is a fair question. "

Mixing Apples & Oranges wrote on March 28, 2007 5:46 pm:
" What this has to do with small business I have yet to figure out. The city has worked with several small businesses that do landscaping and have not been burned. This again, has to do with a City Council person bidding on work that he does not complete. That would explain why the bond company that is required for doing city work has pulled and he had to go to a local bank. Ask any professionally locally owned nursery in town and you will find out it is not about small business but poor performance! And how this relates to mayoral candidate Chris Beutler, that has brought 9 million dollars to the city by grant writing I have yet to figure out! "

LawnMowerMan wrote on March 28, 2007 8:08 pm:
" This seems to be part two of the median story. Remember last Spring when Ray's let the medians get out of control with weeds? "

Define Accountable wrote on March 28, 2007 8:37 pm:
" Ken Svoboda keeps talking about accountability. If he and his supporters whine that printing the true facts of the matter is political rather than taking responsibility for them, then they don't understand the definition of accountability. Remember that Ken didn't vote for a performance audit of Time Warner even though the whole world knows how bad of a job they've done with their new software. Accountability isn't in his dictionary. "

OUT wrote on March 28, 2007 10:39 pm:
" Little wonder the city is in a money shortfall!! Just an example of how Svoboda will spend money on flowers and idiot daisys. He won't get my vote for sure. If we haven't seen enough of this city government, we certainly don't need more to steal our money we don't have!! "

Amused wrote on March 29, 2007 7:54 am:
" Wait till he is mayor and what other contracts his business can have or have the inside track on what the bid should be. Love the good old boy system. "

Oh Please . . . wrote on March 29, 2007 11:25 am:
" If you dig deep enough you will find problems with any candidate for public office. I find it interesting that no one has questioned why Beutler was on the city's payroll at Parks and Rec under Mayor Seng? I also find it interesting that Karl Frederickson chooses now to make this an issue -- trying to protect his job?? "

Politics? wrote on March 29, 2007 12:23 pm:
" First of all,city policies should change, it should be a conflict of interest for a City Council Member's business to have a contract with the city. In my neighborhood we have had trouble with Ray's Lawn Care "caring" for our medians. After numerous photos and complaints to the city regarding the lack of contracted care, Ray's finally mowed the entire overgrown weed patch and then claimed it to be some sort of prairie grass and the median was supposed to be that way. I may not be an expert on horticulture but even I can tell weeds (grown to over 4 ft) from prairie grass. As well, I can tell a con artist from someone whose intentions are honest and forthright and that's all the more reason to support Beutler for Mayor!! "